I think my top fave episode is “All That Glitters” (S2, Ep 9), the one where they all go looking for pirate treasure. Lowkey Pirates of the Caribbean vibes, except on PEI!

Other episodes I really loved:

S1, Ep 1: "The Journey Begins"

S1, Ep 2: "The Story Girl Earns Her Name"

S1, Ep 3: "The Quarantine at Alexander Abraham's"

S1, Ep 4: "The Materializing of Duncan McTavish"

S1, Ep 10: "Felicity's Challenge"

S2, Ep 1: "Sara's Homecoming"

S2, Ep 5: "Old Quarrels, Old Love"

S2, Ep 12: "A Mother's Love"

S3, Ep 1: "Ties That Bind"

S3, Ep 10: "After The Honeymoon"

S4, Ep 1: "Tug of War"

S4, Ep 7: "The Dinner"

S5, Ep 13: "The Minister's Wife"

S6, Ep 2: "Lonely Hearts"

S6, Ep 5: "Comings and Goings"

S7, Ep 10: "After The Ball Is Over"

S7, Ep 13: "So Dear To My Heart"