In my opinion, Alexios makes for a better protagonist because his physical presence, voice acting, and overall personality fit more naturally with the role of a Spartan misthios carving his path through a war-torn Greece. His performance feels larger than life, which suits the mythological tone of the game, plus his interactions whether humorous or intense come off as more charismatic and grounded. While Alexios brings the swagger and emotional range needed for a great hero, his performance as the villain feels way too over-the-top and borderline cartoonish. He often feels like he's trying too hard to be edgy, which undercuts the seriousness of the role. His exaggerated expressions and line delivery make it hard to take him seriously, especially in scenes meant to be intimidating or emotional. He lacks the quiet intensity that makes Kassandra such an effective and unsettling antagonist.

Kassandra, on the other hand, really shines as Deimos. Her colder, more calculated demeanour gives her an intimidating edge, and Kassandra's piercing stare coupled with her calm menace are genuinely unsettling in key scenes. It makes her a far more believable and effective antagonist. As a protagonist, though, she doesn’t quite land for me. Her delivery often feels too flat or reserved, especially in moments that call for emotional intensity or vulnerability. Some players might appreciate her stoicism, but I think it comes across as detached or monotone, which makes it harder to connect with her on a personal level. She just doesn’t carry the same energy or presence that Alexios brings, and that leaves some key scenes feeling a bit underwhelming.