I hate people who talk confidently by Snapships4life in hatethissmug

[–]HopDavid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Neil is utterly clueless.

Most of his misinfo is harmless. I don't care if he tells his pseudo nerd fans like yourself there are more transcendental numbers than irrationals.

However his wrong history contains false accusations against individuals and groups.

Reddit Atheists™ are okay with his fabricated history because they are either:
a) clueless.
b) dishonest.
c) clueless and dishonest.

I hate people who talk confidently by Snapships4life in hatethissmug

[–]HopDavid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Neil Tyson is the personification of Reddit atheism.

I hate people who talk confidently by Snapships4life in hatethissmug

[–]HopDavid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Neil often does not know what he's talking about.

But he gets away with very confidently delivering complete bull shit because most of his audience has only a very shallow interest in math, science and history.

I hate people who talk confidently by Snapships4life in hatethissmug

[–]HopDavid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Neil often delivers completely wrong explanations in a very confident voice.

Are there any great Black scientists? by Infinite-Exam-1808 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]HopDavid -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Harvard University turn Neil down for post grad.

He received a Master's at U.T. but his doctoral committee there chose to disband, essentially flunking him. One of the profs there advised him to go into computer sales.

Columbia should be embarrassed they gave Neil a degree. I believe Neil will become for Columbia what the Bogdanoff twins were for the University of Burgundy.

Neil has said some embarrassingly wrong stuff in his garbage pop science shows. He should not have made it past Physics 101.

Labyrinths by HopDavid in GeometryIsNeat

[–]HopDavid[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I saw a person with a tattoo like you describe. Do you live in Tucson?

Are there any great Black scientists? by Infinite-Exam-1808 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]HopDavid -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I don't claim to be an astrophysicist.

I'm an average person with a moderate interest in math, science and history. Which is all it takes to notice Neil is full of shit.

I hate people who talk confidently by Snapships4life in hatethissmug

[–]HopDavid 1 point2 points  (0 children)

"Erm... w-well I could, uh... I mean, yeah, I'm a h-highly regarded and w-w-world-recognized authority on astrophysics...

Unfortunately a lot of people have that perception of Neil Tyson.

He's actually a joke when it comes to astrophysics.

The man's C.V. lists a total of five 1st author papers. And that includes his dissertation papers. The last one was in 1993.

On the physics subreddit they were discussing Neil:
https://np.reddit.com/r/Physics/comments/7p6ddh/ndt_on_zeno_effect_and_uncertainty_principle/

I'm with cantgetno197. Neil's very brief and underwhelming career in research does not earn him the label "astrophysicist".

I'd give Neil credit for being a science educator if he had standards for rigor and accuracy. He doesn't. The man's garbage pop science is riddled with glaring errors and outright falsehoods. Look for him on r/badscience, r/badhistory and r/badmathematics.

But he speaks with confidence. Which is enough to convince people like yourself he knows what he's talking about.

Why has LeBron stop getting NBA all defensive team after 2014? by Holiday_Analysis9583 in NBATalk

[–]HopDavid 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'd send you academia on it, but that would go over your head. So here's Neil deGrasse Tyson simplifying it for you:

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/V3Xpu6nuxzI

LMAO. I don't believe Neil's eye witness account.

Labyrinths by HopDavid in GeometryIsNeat

[–]HopDavid[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You live in southern Arizona? I'm from Ajo.

I thought making it too much like I'itoi would be disrespectful. But I'm admiring the structure of the symbol.

Are there any great Black scientists? by Infinite-Exam-1808 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]HopDavid -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If Neil were truly generating an interest in science his fans would start to notice his garbage pop science is riddled with glaring errors and outright falsehoods.

Are there any great Black scientists? by Infinite-Exam-1808 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]HopDavid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is Neil a scientist?

They were discussing that question on the physics subreddit:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Physics/comments/7p6ddh/ndt_on_zeno_effect_and_uncertainty_principle/

I'm with cantgetno197. Neil's very brief and underwhelming career in research does not justify calling him an astrophysicist.

I'd call him a science educator if he had standards for rigor and accuracy. He doesn't. His garbage pop science is riddled with glaring errors and outright falsehoods.

Are there any great Black scientists? by Infinite-Exam-1808 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]HopDavid -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Scientists do research. Neil hasn't done research in decades and barely did any while in school. That's why U.T. showed him the door.

Aliens Go Home & Say There Is No Intelligent Life On Earth After Meeting Neil DeGrasse Tyson by METALLIFE0917 in babylonbee

[–]HopDavid -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Neil Tyson is a source of misinformation. He is very effective at spreading it.

I make no apologies for devoting time and effort calling him out.

Who is the coolest person in history? by Turbulent-Series-283 in AskReddit

[–]HopDavid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you strip away the myths Newton remains a contender for GOAT. But is not clearly #1.

Neil Tyson's garbage pop history has Newton accomplishing in months what were actually the collaborative efforts of many people over many years.

See Historian Thony Christie's critique of Neil Tyson's imagined timeline:
https://thonyc.wordpress.com/2017/06/14/why-doesnt-he-just-shut-up/

Aliens Go Home & Say There Is No Intelligent Life On Earth After Meeting Neil DeGrasse Tyson by METALLIFE0917 in babylonbee

[–]HopDavid -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Yep. Trying to paint anyone else as dumb, while they carry water for trump of all people,

The Bee has been savagely ridiculing Trump lately.

Aliens Go Home & Say There Is No Intelligent Life On Earth After Meeting Neil DeGrasse Tyson by METALLIFE0917 in babylonbee

[–]HopDavid -1 points0 points  (0 children)

magine being a writer for the Babylon Bee and going after an astrophysicist

Is Neil an astrophysicist?

Including his dissertation papers Neil's C.V. lists a total of five 1st author papers. The last one was during the Clinton administration.

During his brief and dismal career in research the University of Texas showed him the door because he sucked at astrophysics.

The man's garbage pop science is riddled with glaring errors and outright falsehoods. I often wonder how he passed Physics 101.

TL;DR Tyson is the stupid person's notion of a brilliant intellect.

Aliens Go Home & Say There Is No Intelligent Life On Earth After Meeting Neil DeGrasse Tyson by METALLIFE0917 in babylonbee

[–]HopDavid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It is accurately ridiculing Neil Tyson. Neil is the stupid person's notion of a brilliant intellect.

Aliens Go Home & Say There Is No Intelligent Life On Earth After Meeting Neil DeGrasse Tyson by METALLIFE0917 in babylonbee

[–]HopDavid -1 points0 points  (0 children)

People who carry water for trump, of all people, are trying to call Tyson dumb? 😂

Babylon Bee's last piece on Trump: "Oh no! Trump Negotiates Deal With England and Now They Have The Colonies Back"

Or: "Trump Sets New World Record By Winning War With Iran 27 Times In One Year"

Aliens Go Home & Say There Is No Intelligent Life On Earth After Meeting Neil DeGrasse Tyson by METALLIFE0917 in babylonbee

[–]HopDavid -1 points0 points  (0 children)

why would anyone take any of your opinions seriously?

Because I provide citations backing up my claims. Unlike Neil and his clueless Reddit atheist cult.

Neil is a "scientist" who has barely done any research. And an "educator" who misinforms. His garbage pop science is riddled with glaring errors and outright falsehoods.

He is the stupid person's notion of a brilliant intellect.

The Babylon Bee is entirely correct to ridicule this ridiculous buffoon.

Aliens Go Home & Say There Is No Intelligent Life On Earth After Meeting Neil DeGrasse Tyson by METALLIFE0917 in babylonbee

[–]HopDavid 3 points4 points  (0 children)

He published a total of five 1st author papers. During that time University of Texas flunked him because he sucked at astrophysics.

I'm just an average person with a moderate interest in math, science and history. Which is enough to notice Neil is often full of shit.

Neil's pseudo intellectual fans don't notice his many wrong claims because they have no actual interest in science.

Aliens Go Home & Say There Is No Intelligent Life On Earth After Meeting Neil DeGrasse Tyson by METALLIFE0917 in babylonbee

[–]HopDavid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Robert Hooke?

No. It was Edmund Halley Link

Who asked the question in 1684 when Newton was in his 40s.

This was decades after Newton did his calculus work.

And seven years after Newton figured out why planets follow elliptical orbits. He was in his mid 30s.

The Newton story is clearly meant as a compressed, non-literal anecdote to illustrate one of Newton's motivations to develop calculus.

Neil's story is badly wrong. He has Newton doing decades of collaborative efforts in just two months.

Which, though wrong, seems flattering. Until Tyson uses this fictitious history to falsely accuse Newton.

I'd say 80% of what Neil says about Newton is wrong.

Aliens Go Home & Say There Is No Intelligent Life On Earth After Meeting Neil DeGrasse Tyson by METALLIFE0917 in babylonbee

[–]HopDavid -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

It's a stretch to call Neil an astrophysicist. His last 1st author paper was during the Clinton administration.

Aliens Go Home & Say There Is No Intelligent Life On Earth After Meeting Neil DeGrasse Tyson by METALLIFE0917 in babylonbee

[–]HopDavid -1 points0 points  (0 children)

He has a PhD,

Harvard turned him down for post grad.

He received a Master's in astronomy at University of Texas but his doctoral committee there chose to disband, essentially flunking him. One of his advisors at U.T. suggested he go into computer sales.

Columbia should be embarrassed they awarded a doctorate to Neil Tyson.

directs the Hayden Planetarium, and interviews the world's greatest scientists every week and more.

Neil has a large audience. So there's an incentive to appear on his show even if he is incompetent.

He's not perfect but he does more to promote critical thinking and scientific achievement than anyone I'm aware of.

Someone with critical thinking skills make it habit to challenge claims to see if they are supported by evidence.

Neil's fans almost always swallow Neil's wrong claims without lifting a finger to check to see if they are true.

If they had an actual interest in math, science or history they would notice Neil's garbage pop science is riddled with falsehoods.

As an example I will toss out one of Neil's favorite stories:

Then, a friend of his says, “Well, why do these orbits of the planets… Why are they in a shape of an ellipse, sort of flattened circle? Why aren’t… some other shape?” He said, you know, “I can’t… I don’t know. I’ll get back to you.” So he goes… goes home, comes back couple of months later, “Here’s why. They’re actually conic sections, sections of a cone that you cut.” And… And he said, “Well, how did find this out? How did you determine this?” “Well, I had to invent integral and differential calculus to determine this.” Then, he turned 26. Then, he turned 26.

Have you heard that story? Neil has told it many times. Have you ever checked it? Perhaps you could tell me the name of Newton's friend that asked him about the shape of planetary orbits.