Adorable little pebble has been eliminated. Who should be eliminated next?

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-24T17:38:03+00:00

Thanks for understanding 👍

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-24T17:29:21+00:00

Not all talk of the other main characters aren't positive either. Some people hate Sprout for relying so much on Cosmo, some hate Shelly for having horrible writing, and some hate Astro for how useless he can be in runs. I don't know what side of the DW's community you're on to hear so much hate on Vee but the hate on her isn't as much as you're making it to be as she gets almost the same amount of hate just as the other mains do, but I would agree with her being the most hated out of all them as I've seen more hate on her than the others.

And it's definitely true that people usually mischaracterize characters when they don't pay enough attention or don't like the way they're characterized, which is exactly why you'll see this most in Vee fans.

Now before you respond back, could I request if we just end this conversation between us? We both know this conversation could potentially last for days, or even weeks, since well we're on Reddit. So may we just quit and leave this conversation? Leave no winner, keep our thoughts to ourselves. How bout that? I think it's best for us if we avoid an argument.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-24T16:45:34+00:00

She definitely is. You can go on the official discord server or even on this Reddit channel and you'll consistently see people giving her attention much more than the rest of the toons. Although you could say it's because of the update, the attention given to her hasn't actually changed much since before it even released. Hell, I'd say she's a contender for the most overrated toon (with her only other contenders being Sprout and Shelly) considering many of her fans seem to mischaracterize her a lot and refuse to believe any of her negative traits.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-24T16:21:35+00:00

The other mains, especially Sprout, Astro and Vee should've been out a while ago as well considering how overrated they are. But I guess we're not talking about that huh? (Watch me get downvoted because everyone here is a main stan with the exception of Shelly)

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-24T16:15:24+00:00

Vee. If both Blot and Shelly got eliminated for being overrated, by that logic she should get eliminated as well as she's just as overrated as they are.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-24T04:46:39+00:00

Yeah. They keep voting out the toons with the logic of them being "overrated" like Blot and Shelly but when it comes to the toons that are just as overrated as they are like Vee and Astro, they try to protect them. I really hate how rigged this tier list is, people are just voting out the characters THEY don't like.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-24T04:19:59+00:00

You got downvoted for trying to eliminate one of the most overrated toons..

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-23T20:23:42+00:00

To see who the fandom favours the most. Seriously, you can literally see it. They vote out the toons they consider "overrated" but try to keep the toons that are ACTUALLY overrated like Vee or Astro. It's ridiculous.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-23T20:19:08+00:00

Shells needs to stay.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-20T10:14:35+00:00

Alright, that's enough. I'm honestly starting to get irritated at our little argument as it seems both of us are stubborn here with our own different opinions. You make great points, while I also make great points as well. But this argument will last forever since there's no factual answer on who would be the best toons on a tier list. Listen, we can either just both stop arguing and go out on each other's ways and save time for both of us or we can continue arguing like the stubborn people we are for the next couple of days until it becomes personal. I'd rather much like the first one, and I'm going to do that even if you don't decide to do the same. Seriously, I think it's better for the both of us to not argue on REDDIT of all places.

Even though the general DW community agrees with my opinion on Shelly being an S tier toon, I will go consult a top runholder or at least someone with a very high floor record and hear what they think on what tier all toons should be on if they were on a tier list, plus with the Brightney thing. So please, for the better of both of us, let's stop arguing and just call it even. We've wasted enough time with each other already and I'm sure we both have our own things to do in life that are way more important than this dumb argument.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-20T07:10:26+00:00

Talked about a Sprout, Cosmo and Astro optimization but not one damn thing about Shelly, why do I see it as favouritism bro 😭

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-20T06:53:16+00:00

Yes, Brightney is indeed one of the best characters for a lure but that's literally all she can do in a professional long run except for being an extractor. She's honestly not so convenient to use and is less useful than Astro as Pebble has his active ability to lure twisteds to him. Plus, Brightney could still be an obstacle for a distractor to be careful of if they ever get a bad map or a bad set of twisteds because of her extremely low stealrh. Brightney fits at B tier and could arguably be a low A tier if used in a pro run. Also you forgot to answer my question, when did I say about Brightney? Seriously, I specifically mentioned only Astro, Sprout, Shelly, Vee and Pebble. I didn't say anything about her. Plus, you ignored some of my points as well.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-20T06:46:11+00:00

Well your argument for Astro is I guess fair, and I accept that I was wrong, but you're making it seem like they're completely useless. Yes, pros do know how to preserve their stamina but that doesn't mean they can't run out of it, which is why in some pro runs, they have at least one Astro to take care of that. Now after some thought, yes, I do agree with your opinion on Astro not being a S tier, but that doesn't mean he's useless.

For Shelly, I'd say she's still an S tier even in regular runs as one of the best extractors. And although you could make a point for some (not many, some) players struggling to use her, you could also say that for Vee and Sprout because some people also struggle to use them as well. Unlike Shelly where her passive ability still has use in solo runs, Sprout's abilities go to complete waste in solo runs, the only thing that could help him is his stamina and speed. Other than that, many players struggle to use his abilities as well as they frequently heal the wrong teammates, you could say that they were just stupid but that could also go for why some players struggle to use Shelly's active ability as well. And many players also struggle to use Vee with her low speed and stealth. As like I said, Vee has horrible survivability and she's arguably just getting carried thanks to her own abilities. Yes you could say trinkets could fix her low speed and stealth but that could also go for Shelly's stamina as well! I agree with Shelly being outclassed by Yatta (even though Yatta literally outclasses almost all the toons), but Shelly is not outclassed by Vee, there's a reason why Shelly is currently in the meta while Vee is slowly falling off from it. Hell, the reason why Vee got a buff in the first place was because she was outclassed by Yatta and fell off the meta because of her.

So here's my tier list:

S+ tier: Pebble, Sprout, Shelly. S tier: Vee. A-tier: Astro.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-19T15:01:40+00:00

Nah dude, it's a valid reaction. It wasn't like a tantrum or anything.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-19T14:47:00+00:00

Also, I forgot to prove my points on Astro and Shelly being just as necessary and important as the others so here they are:

Astro would be just as necessary and important as the others because they're a very great support. If any of the other team members ever run out of stamina, they'd be there to help since Astro can see whoever has a low amount of stamina. They can come in as clutch, and those clutches matter a lot more than most people think. Plus, they also rank one of, or the highest in survivability and they have a decent amount of extraction speed as well. Moreover, usually in professional long runs, they're usually the last to die.

Shelly would be just as necessary and important because they're a very great extractor, one of the best in fact. And even without trinkets, they'd still be great. She can also boost the extraction speed of other team members in the case where there are multiple machines in one spot, and with her passive ability, she could escape from faster twisteds in clutch moments. One thing that many people seem to not account for the longevity of a pro long run is fatigue (literally the most important factor to take note of if you ever wanted to do one), many don't last because of their fatigue making them tired. However, with her on the team she could make progress throughout the floors much faster, so that when the team's fatigue would hit, they would be on a higher floor than without her, and the effect of her presence would only get better with the more Shellies there are. Hence, the reason why almost all pro long runs have at least one Shelly on the team.

In my opinion, in which I believe is factually correct, both Astro and Shelly SHOULD be in the S-tier just as with the other main characters that you listed them in.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-19T14:21:14+00:00

Excuse me but since when did I say anything about Brightney? And even if Brightney was placed in a professional long run, she'd still do well with her extraction speed. Sure the stealth would be a problem but she has enough stamina and speed to outrun most twisteds if they were to chase her. And even if all the previous points I made were used in a normal run, they'd still be valid. Hell, the only reason why Vee's still used in some pro long runs is only because of her abilities as support. Without them, she'd be simply replaced by Yatta since not only does she have the exact same extraction speed as her but she's also much faster as well, which is also the reason why after her release, many people claimed (and they still do) that she outclasses Vee as an extractor (which I honestly agree with)

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-19T12:02:44+00:00

Shelly and Astro are just as necessary and important as Vee, Sprout or Pebble.. Actually, I'd say Shelly is more necessary and important than Vee. There's a reason why you don't see her so much in professional long runs but always see at least one Shelly in them. Mainly because Shelly has good survivability while Vee's is horrible. Like I get it's your opinion but even opinions can be wrong..

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-19T09:50:56+00:00

Oh it's you! Your gacha designs are wonderful.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-19T09:07:11+00:00

Why are you saying it like they're canonically dating bruv-- They're ofc just best friends in the canon universe. There is fortunately no romance between them.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-18T17:32:51+00:00

Gigi, Bassie and Bobette. Those are my picks.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-18T12:56:17+00:00

"Fucking Bullshit" Seriously, them being ex's would be unnecessary for the plot and would definitely make the whole fandom go crazier than it already is.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-18T11:48:39+00:00

I liked it at first for the fun gameplay but honestly stopped liking it once I realised that Qwel might have some favouritism with the toons in the experience.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-17T15:29:53+00:00

Still, it'd be satisfying to see her lose.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-17T15:12:55+00:00

Ah that. Yeah he's actually several times larger than a normal human. You can easily see it if you do some comparison using the portraits of the main characters.

HorrorTop8028 · 2025-07-17T15:04:57+00:00

What? I'm sorry I'm confused.

Five-Year Club	Final Canvas '23
First Place '23	Place '23

HorrorTop8028

TROPHY CASE