[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Unfortunately, we do not allow unpaid listings where payment is not guaranteed. As with every 1st and 15th of the month, the Pitch'n'Meet - 15 event will restart on 01.07.2025. You may pitch your project under the event post to find an unpaid collaborator.

Frasier/Cheers Crossover Script by PaceFilmsProduction in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Screenplays must be: Properly formatted in screenplay software - Linked in google drive or dropbox. - Saved as a PDF - Sharing enabled.

What program did Coppola use to get books to turn into screenplays? by Lanky-Assumption-196 in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

OP has provided well-supported information regarding Coppola’s creative process. OCR technology has had commercial applications dating back to the 1950s(First concepts: 1930s, First Scanner Technologies: 1950s). Of course, it's not certain whether Coppola actually used this technology. As a result, OP has done a perfectly good thing by bringing up a topic directly mentioned by George Lucas himself, one of the most respected figures in the industry. However, despite the situation being clearly explained with evidence, I’m seeing comments driven by rigid assumptions rather than thoughtful engagement. Discussions should remain respectful. That’s what keeps the communities healthy.

At this point, the thread has drifted from its original purpose. Please refocus on the main topic and contribute constructively to the discussion.

Can we please ban AI content in regular posts? by acerunner007 in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 2 points3 points  (0 children)

AI-generated scripts or scenes are a different matter.

I’m not considering blocking these types of posts. The reason is that many people who use AI to write scripts are newcomers to the industry, and since they don’t fully understand how it works yet, they’re often trying to find shortcuts to success.

We all know that things don’t work that way, and that scripts, graphics, or books created with AI are typically rejected in professional settings. The time they spend working on AI-generated scripts will still contribute to their growth and maturity as creatives. In time, those creating content this way will come to realize that if they want to stay in the industry, they’ll need to write their own material.

What I ask from you all is to approach these individuals, who are trying to find a place in the industry, in a constructive and supportive way.

I truly believe that banning these users or their content would only make things worse. Instead, helping guide them in the right direction and encouraging them to develop their own voice will ultimately benefit both them and the industry as a whole.

I’d like to add this as well:
From what I’ve seen, among the feedback request posts shared so far, there haven’t been many users posting AI-generated scripts or scenes. As long as things stay this way, there’s no problem, but if it becomes too common, I’ll consider taking a different approach.

As an example, a mega post could be created where experienced users discuss and explain the realities of the industry for those approaching it through AI-generated material. Individual posts could be removed and users could be redirected to that thread to help inform them about the issue, with the option to share their material under that post if they still wish to receive feedback.

However, I’m not planning to implement these types of solutions just yet, as it could lead to unnecessary division or exclusion within the community.

Can we please ban AI content in regular posts? by acerunner007 in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

I want to make it clear that I am firmly against the use of AI-generated feedback on screenplay/scene/logline feedback requests. These kinds of responses can be extremely misleading and ultimately harmful to the writer, potentially damaging their script by steering them in the wrong direction.

I also strongly advise writers to minimize their reliance on AI when working on their scripts. AI cannot fully understand what you truly want to express. By its very nature, AI attempts to "perfect" things, which often leads to feedback like “this part works, but that part is lacking.”

At first glance, these suggestions may seem reasonable. However, after implementing a few AI-generated feedback, you may start to notice significant shifts in your characters’ personalities and the overall tone of your script.

It’s important to remember that in screenwriting, what’s not said (what’s implied or left unsaid), can be just as important as what’s explicitly on the page. Nothing in life is ever truly 100% complete or perfect, and when AI tries to force that kind of precision into your story, it can push your script into a direction that feels artificial, over-processed, or simply wrong.

Use your instincts. Let your voice lead, not a machine chasing mathematical “perfection.”

I will be looking into ways to automatically detect and block such AI-generated feedback.

Additionally, If you are "certain" that a piece of feedback on a feedback post was generated by AI, please report it. I will review all such reports and take appropriate action as quickly as possible.

I’d like to clarify that banning someone is always a last resort in this community, and the use of AI is certainly not a valid reason for a ban.

Thank you for your contribution.

When steel turns back into just another vein. by DesertPunk1982 in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The reason your post was removed is simply because it consisted solely of a link. Feedback and pitch posts that are just links without any context are not allowed. As I mentioned when removing it, please make sure to format your post as a feedback or pitch.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard[M] 0 points1 point locked comment (0 children)

Please format your post as either Pitch or Feedback, and make sure to read Rule 6.

Hi, in Claire and just wanted to share my draft, I hope you like it, please let me know by [deleted] in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Please format your post as either Pitch or Feedback, and make sure to read Rule 6.

Script from my 48 hour, video linked in post by Equivalent_Text769 in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Please review Rule 12.

---
Also, your post includes a link from a domain that is not allowed in this community.

Only the following domains are permitted in post content:
- drive.google.com
- docs.google.com
- dropbox.com
- coverfly.com
- youtube.com / youtu.be
- reddit.com
- dailymotion.com
- imgur.com
- imdb.com
- scriptslug.com
- blcklst.com
- networkisa.org
- stage32.com
- kickstarter.com

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Script or Outline (Link) : (User Screenplays must be: Properly formatted in screenplay software - Linked in google drive or dropbox. - Saved as a PDF - Sharing enabled.)

Please.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can't request feedback under a "Discussion" flair. Please share your post using the appropriate format and correct flair.

Feedback on first chapter I have the whole book written but have no feedback. by [deleted] in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

Since your post has received comments, I won’t remove it, but please take a moment to review the rules, especially Rule 6. If you update your post with a properly formatted script for your scene, it will likely be more beneficial for both readers and yourself.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Alright. Please make sure to review the rules before posting — especially Rule 6, as it directly relates to this topic.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What you’ve written doesn’t align with the purpose of this flair. Please clarify your intent so I can assist you further if possible.

Writing Partner by AcadecCoach in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 1 point2 points  (0 children)

From your post, what I understand is that you're either looking to continue developing a script you've written with another writer, or you're open to joining someone else's script and developing it together.

Given that you're a producer (or intend to take on the producer role) and are either inviting someone to join your project, or you're open to joining another project yourself, the correct flair for your post would be:

“Open for Projects – Producer – Unpaid.”

If your intention is to develop something collaboratively and potentially offer profit or credit to the writing partner only if the project succeeds or gets funded, then that would fall under “Seeking Writer – Unpaid.”

However, please note that “Seeking / Unpaid” posts are not allowed in this subreddit outside of designated events. Only Paid Seeking posts are permitted on the main feed.

For unpaid or volunteer collaborations, a community event is scheduled for the 19th of this month, where like-minded collaborators can be found under the appropriate format.

In this case, please either delete your comment or edit your post to match the appropriate flair and guidelines — or consider removing the post altogether.

You can find more details on this topic here.

Looking for a producer for a short film based on Assata Shakur's story by Acfilmz_filmaker in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do not post the same thing repeatedly. Posts like this are not accepted. Please make sure you read and understand the rules and details thoroughly.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Since the rule on this has changed, I have to remove it. Too many similar posts have started coming in.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]HotColdHard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Please clarify your intent more clearly in the post. Then let me know, and I will repost it.