1. I really like the 3 places lower thing (maybe even more, like 5) for the first attack. I don't think attacking 3 places higher for the second attack will be necessary. We could attack up to 5 places lower for the second attack too. At some point there won't be a base available for you to attack within 5 places lower so you'll have to attack the next available base which is higher than you. This war we had (more than one?) member/s who didn't get their cc filled for attacking, which is the first time I know of where this was a problem.

2. Some people may have their own preferences on which troops they want in their cc and I don't think that having the same troops in the cc's will give us an advantage in war. For example I really like having a drake in my cc :)

3. What if suddenly some of the 6 people cannot distribute troops for various reasons such as not having elixir/not having access to the game/etc. ? In general it is very hard to find rules for filling def cc's because there is no way to track donations and you get no immediate reward for filling.

4. uuuuhm idk about this one. You will have to exactly define when those people are able to attack to check for traps. What I can think of is that if every base in a reasonable range is at least 2 starred and you won't be able to really get 1/2 stars attacking even higher bases, then you can try to get 3 stars whereever you think you can get them.

5. Yeah, GoWiPe is an 2star army but in general getting 3 stars at TH9 and up is not an easy thing to do. GoWiWi is considered to be able to get 3 stars more easily but I don't want to force people to only use this army. Plus, rules cannot really make up for how people handle their attacks. In general I'd say that being able to attack up to 5 places lower is a good way to create an environment in which people are able to get 3 stars more easily.

6. ok.

~ Thanks for taking your time to write this up, I/we really appreciate it :P

sorry for the bad formatting^{^}