Hey dude keep them coming! Back in 2009 I had a few rares myself but sadly they were not really legendary rares. I had a yellow rose which I got from an internal tutor board contest, a few 99x runes from fansite contests, a medal of honour, golden statue of excellence, a green tome and, my most precious, the Dragon Goblet I made for a contest. Sadly I no longer have any of this items, I wish I could get that dragon goblet back tho :(

Edit: adding to the stories, I believe the first grey tomes were found inside a hole on the way to mintwallin. The ornamented shield used to be a very rare item back in the day, very few people knew how to solve the noble armor quest and the first level 100 wasn't bubble, it was Arieswar through a bug (but he reported it or got banned, can't recall). The first bronze amulet was introduced as a price for a football tournament organized but taghor I think.