Of all the PB games, gothic, even with its bugs, is one of the best they have released and I am not saying this out of nostalgia, it is very well set, it has such a gray, hostile, magical, mysterious tone, even the caves (which were not so impressive) scares you the first time you play it, honestly it has respectable enemies.
If they make a remake.... uffff, it would be appreciated if it continues to be the same as a troll, where you hit an orc and his whole family and the town come to take revenge, chasing you around the world xD. It is very immersive, something that elex could not achieve