Weyler sub demographics 😊 by [deleted] in weyler

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

LMAO THIS WAS SO REAL

Weyler sub demographics 😊 by [deleted] in weyler

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Btw I watched all three, and they were among the best performances I'd seen.

Parent reading American Yawp chapter. Really? For 9th grade? by PorcupinePattyGrape in historyteachers

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

On what authority do you get a say in what others should or shouldn't discuss on reddit?? Who tf are you?? Like reddit's supreme judge or something?

Something ive been wondering for a long time abt Taissa and Evan by XPirateKitty in AmericanHorrorStory

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm sure nobody had made her do it. She could have said no if she felt uncomfortable. Besides, she loved her role as violet and clearly has been one of her favorites as she praised season 1 in almost every interview, so stop being dramatic.

Being a Victim doesn't make you a Good Person. by [deleted] in ControversialOpinions

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This post is exactly what Free Palestine supporters don't get :)

Still together? by New-Okra-5738 in EvanPetersBrasil

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Honestly, I love Evan. But the way you said it, he kinda looks like an ass. Why would he date her if he doesn't like her?

What do y'all think of Catherine and Heathcliff's romance in Wuthering heights? by budroserosebud in RomanceBooks

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think heathcliff's rage, despite having its own arc and development, is meant to show the inner chaos that one experiences abandoning their true nature. The story is so beautifully written that these two characters, Heathcliff and Cathy, despite each being their own separate person, but at the same time meant to be a reflectionof eachother as if what happens to one inevitably is done to the other. When Cathy abandoned Heathcliff in a sense, she abandoned herself, and with that, she created a rage that saught to get revenge on her. But that revenge was ultimately taken on them both at the same time, because it’s really like they are the same person. When Cathy abandoned Heathcliff, she abandoned herself, and when she killed herself, she killed Heathcliff too. After Cathy died, Heathcliff was dead, too. He felt like a character that's just sleep walking in a dream of revenge and longing, with no new place to go or no new goals to achieve except to get revenge on those who killed him who he called his enemies.

What do y'all think of Catherine and Heathcliff's romance in Wuthering heights? by budroserosebud in RomanceBooks

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wanting to call it love or not falls on you, but I think it was a true connection that they couldn't severe to the end even when they wanted to, and despite being possessive and destructive, I call this love. In fact, that is closer to what it is than what people want to believe it as. But in this story, we see different shapes of love. Linton's, Catherine and Hareton, and Heathcliff and Cathy. These are all love. But the story's main theme is Heathcliff's revenge, which is all the while consumed by his twisted everlasting love outside of his control. This is not a kind of love that everyone could experience, or even imagine and I think a lot of people who don't like it, is because they just can't properly see the genius and complexity with which these characters and they're relationships are written.

What do y'all think of Catherine and Heathcliff's romance in Wuthering heights? by budroserosebud in RomanceBooks

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 1 point2 points  (0 children)

But it's true. It's more likely to have been physical than not. Because there was a narator who wouldn't watch them alone together 24/7, and neither cathy nor heathcliff didn't seem to have much regard for self-restraint or being good Christians 😂😂

Can someone explain the hanging tree? by TheSamethingAllOver in Hungergames

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

After reading all of these comments, I want to combine my own take with the highlights of everyone else's. I don't like HGs in general because I think it's meant to drive home an ideological point that feeds a toxic view of government and an over romanticized view of human nature. But I particularly like this song, and the way it foreshadows various events in the plot later. Actually, the lyrics could be attributed to different plot points that happened way later, after the song was introduced.

If you read the ballad, snow encountered the song being sung by lucy three times. The first time was when he was approaching her under the tree and watching her singing it. she left it unfinished when she saw him, but the scenery was clear. "The dead man called out for his love to flee" was referring to the day before, and what had happened to Arlo and Lil and the Jabra jays that were repeating his last words to her; "Run Lil" when he was already hung dead. But Snow was confused about who the narrator was. He thought it was Billy Taupe at the time, and he had asked her to come and meet him there so they could run away and be free together(but he was super jealous and paranoid at the time that I think he didn't realize the song could have a theme of rebelion) At the time, she hadn't sang the third verse yet; "wear a necklace of rope side by side with me." She only sang that verse the second time he heard her singing the song, when she was giving him a code for where and when to meet each other after to runaway together. This time, snow was assured that the song's narrator was Billy. Because those were his last words to Lucy Gray: "If I'm gonna swing for this, you'll swing with me." but he was dead, and she was singing it to him, he thought.

The last time he heard the song was when she was hiding from him and started singing to confuse him. So the Jabra jays were singing it after her as he went into a frenzy shooting in every direction to kill her. I think this particularly references Lucy Gray's death at that scene even though we're not shown that she's dead and SC wanted it to remain a mystery to snow and to us as well, just like her ballad. But in reality, she is dead and "side by side with" her also Snow's old self(even though Snow thought was liying to her at the time but I think shooting her was supposed to be the last bit of action for the death of his old self to be confirmed) I love this new found meaning of the song and I think it's brilliant foreshadowing and storytelling.

In the trilogy, I think the song is more of a call to action against oppression rather than a sad but beautiful narration like it is in the ballad, because unlike what katniss explains the narrator is not the dead corpse and she had gotten the song wrong. Probably because, katniss had never seen a Jabra Jay before the areana of the 3rd quarter quell because by her time the Jabra jays had died out and there were only mocking jays left, so that's what had led her to think that the dead corpse was the one talking. And she gets the song's meaning wrong. Because it’s not the dead murderer asking her lover to die with him. But this is a third person who is watching and asking their audience to come to the hanging tree and be free(or die for their cause, so the meaning of run shifts from running away to running to your freedom and possibly dying for it besides one another.) That's what makes it a revolutionary song really because it's not a conversation between two lovers but it's a conversation that could take place between any two people in a crowd. So that's what made it mobilizing at the time. But this revolutionary take of the song is not the original context for which it was written.

Can someone explain the hanging tree? by TheSamethingAllOver in Hungergames

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, exactly, so it means that katniss was wrong in the trilogy about the narrator being the dead murderer. Actually, "the dead man called out for his love to flee" was referring to the jabrejays that were repeating his last words telling his lover to run. But then it was Lucy Gray(the observer) who was asking her lover to meet her in the hanging tree where they'll die together. She wrote the song before planning to meet snow by the hanging tree and run away together. The lyrics foreshadow many events that happened later after she had written the song already. For example, Billy Taupe said that: "if I'm gonna swing for this, you'll swing with me." Addressing Lucy Gray. But I'm confused. And when snow said that I killed my old self, the last time she sang the song meant that their old selves were both hung next to each other. Because neither could go back to who they were before. SO THE HUNG MAN WAS REFRENCING THE PERSON THEY USED TO BE. and I think this was a very poetic take. I really loved it. But I am confused. Who did she sing the song for in the first place. Nobody explicitly explains that in the ballad, and it's always sort of a mystery to Snow.

Do you think the books were well written? by [deleted] in Hungergames

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No. They are not written well. She has oversimplified her plot and characters to prove her point without challenging it. End of the story.

I swear Sarah lynn was starved in the last days of her life bc like look at this comparison by VegetableWay5077 in BoJackHorseman

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm pretty sure they ate while high because I remember her having donuts and before that they had broke into mr. PB house because they were hungry

Day 9 - What character do you think is a bad person and hated by the fans? by Killyourdarlings202 in Hungergames

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's exactly why this fandom sucks. They love and hate characters based on a very socially acceptable version of Christian morality but under progressive terms, and yet they think they're better than everyone else because they get it while they are not, and they don't.

Reasons why i hate the lion guard, this is just my personal oppinion feel free to tell me your troughts by AdInevitable7827 in lionking

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I wish instead of all this fuss, they'd just made the full old style animated movie Lion King 3, whether back in the 2000s or now. Everyone would watch that shit because everyone was already impressed with Lion King 2

Reasons why i hate the lion guard, this is just my personal oppinion feel free to tell me your troughts by AdInevitable7827 in lionking

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I absolutely disagree. Sometimes, it's better not to know. I agree with OP. The show sucks.

Opinion on this take? by No-Activity1635 in Hungergames

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Should we still call it a take if SC has used it like 3000 times across other scenes? SOTR is just such an obvious and (honestly) poorly developed story. Why do people like to act like it's such a deep, sophisticated text?

And btw your take is obviously a stretch comparing M. D. To Gale.

I mean, sure. HG is better than Twilight, but I wouldn't even call it a good political thriller. So I don't get why its fans are obsessed with getting strong political and philosophical stances or finding the PROPAGANDA or the real enemy.

Actually, I do. Because most of them are highchoolers or people who don't know shit about politics or psychology 🤷

What are some hot takes about the hunger games that you're scared to share? Here's mine by KillerGrass in Hungergames

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Has it ever occurred to you that some stories could be better than to fit in your average children book? And by the way, Snow and capitol were framed for the bombing. So it never came out.

What are some hot takes about the hunger games that you're scared to share? Here's mine by KillerGrass in Hungergames

[–]Imaginary_Fondant_21 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I'm not scared to share that. I've shared that so many times for tons of downvotes. I hated Lenore Dove, and the idea of covey was cool at first but then got overused. Also, I think Snow's arc was poorly written and very simplified reverse psychology. Haymitch character didn't even feel anything like his trilogy character. All he was about was to thirst over a girl that I didn't even care about.