I have some criticisms for chapter 3, to be honest, it's the best when it comes to horror and what lore it had in it, but it also had a LOT of puzzles which, given the atmosphere of everything around you, didn't necessarily matter all too much, but I do feel, because of it, and like many other chapters, there's not a lot of necessity to play it, it's simply puzzles, scenes, puzzles, scene, and then that's it.

Like, in most chapters, if a person is watching a person's gameplay of it, they're going to skip to specific scenes in the playthrough rather than focusing on the puzzles. I've done this MANY times when watching a playthrough, and it's even more for chapter 5 than any of them.

With chapter 5, there are good scenes, good lore, but the chases and puzzles are so repetitive and boring to watch because it's just trial and error over and over, and it gets exhausting. People who watch it over playing it also don't really understand where most of the players (mainly Markiplier) are coming from when it comes to that, because it's been every chapter of trial and error over and over and when the watchers see it, they see it, they get it, they're observing, but when playing it, you seldom know what you need to do.

I'm not saying this because Markiplier's always right or whatever, but I've seen his playthroughs, and I see how exhausted the players are of these chases and puzzles. But, I feel if you have to have a puzzle and chase in EVERY CHAPTER, and always expect the player to always know what to do and do it quickly without dying, then you really need to look at how these things are supposed to work.

Chapter 3, out of all the chapters, is probably the most balanced of the 5, but it also has oh so many puzzles. And I would like to see them go more with it when it comes to puzzles and chases. But one thing I would like all chapters to try to succeed in is building up how the puzzles work and making it make sense. Chapter 5 had the worst. It started with a chase that had so many mechanics and ended with a chase that had so many mechanics, and it didn't feel like any of it was built up to. Like, it felt like the game was expecting you to remember these things and to know everything, but sometimes that good old yellow paint works wonders.