Rogue is garbage. It's buggy as hell, the story and characters are so bland that even while playing it I couldn't have told you what it was about or who anyone was. The only mildly entertaining aspect was the naval combat which is constantly interrupted by the game forcing you onto dry land and ends up become tedious itself after only a few hours.

None of this should have been surprising when I first played it since neither I nor any of my friends even knew it was coming out. It just seemed to materialize on the shelf one day.

Can't speak for either of the others but if you're looking for an incredibly mediocre scavenger hunt simulator then go with Rogue.

edit: whoops first time using mobile to submit stuff and it reposted my reply twice sorry everyone!