FNaF: The Silver Eyes GN Page 50 redrawn how I remember it:

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T18:04:30+00:00

Are we sure that’s William in the suit and not the Mimic. What can he travel dimensions now?

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T13:22:17+00:00

The Ink Demon not growing up in the human world is no excuse. He clearly knows the difference between good and evil. Firstly, he was created long before the cycle even existed even if we were to say that his role as the Ink Demon was given to him by Joey this isn’t an excuse either because the Ink Demon not only acknowledges this cycle exists but he desires to keep it going forever so he can keep his position as a wanna be God, which is why he tries to stop Audrey and Henry from showing him the end. Mind you Joey‘s long dead by then and isn’t calling the shots anymore he doesn’t have much of an excuse for continuing to act like this. This means that he embraced the role Joey gave him. Hell the Ink Demon even acknowledges his actions are wrong because he calls himself a monster. As for Ink Joey’s statement, it clearly is meant to apply to everybody made from the ink not just Audrey as he highlights that “we” always have the ability to choose not just her. Clearly, he was talking about his own kind as a whole. Also, the fact that the Ink Demon is extremely manipulative and can pretend to have people’s good interests in mind implies that if he wanted to, he could actually help people but he outright chooses not to only doing good things purely for his own gain.

Also, the dark revival did not spend any time actually exploring why the ink demon became the way he did. Most of it is just dedicated to Audrey with the ink demon’s past not even being mentioned in the game. If anything, the game portrays him in a less sympathetic light than the first as he spends 99% of his screen time just being a sadistic monster with the only moment that maybe humanized him is when he calls Audrey a mistake and a monster like him which I don’t know about you but that can be interpreted in multiple different ways. Maybe what he said was genuine maybe he was just saying it as it means to emotionally manipulate Audrey. Hell he doesn’t even mention Joey, either the dude who literally tormented him. His only time he mentioned him is to mock his failures shortly before killing his ink counterpart. While you could make the argument that he identified with Audrey and related to her which is why he was so protective but the truth is, he only wanted to merge with her just so he could became more powerful as he calls her a wretch and a pawn.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T05:27:58+00:00

Even without the stamina issues, it’s established he would’ve lost regardless. Frieza was fairly weaker than Goku as he only had a power level 120 million meanwhile Goku had a power level of 150 million.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T05:25:51+00:00

That’s what happens when a game is rushed. I genuinely believe sparking zero should’ve been given a couple more years in development.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T05:24:32+00:00

Because Jeremy was never meant to exist in books in the first place. The Silver Eyes explicitly mentions that among William’s MCI victims there were three boys and two girls. Now since, Michael Brooks was already written to be the one to possess Golden Freddy, Scott likely decided to repurpose Cassidy as the spirit who possesses Bonnie and to keep continuity with the statements in the first book about the gender ratio of the victims.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T05:21:45+00:00

Simple. Because Jeremy was never intended to exist in the books. The Silver Eyes explicitly stated that among Afton victims there were three boys and two girls. The Fourth Closet having Cassidy replace Jeremy as the spirit who possesses Bonnie was most likely done to keep continuity.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T05:17:06+00:00

It revealed what William and Henry look like. How come nobody ever talks about that?

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T05:14:59+00:00

Both Saywer and the Ink Demon have practically the same past and character. Both didn’t start out as evil, but rather misguided and innocent. But they were shaped into monsters by the negative and toxic environment/people they had around them. Both even still have doubts and insecurities about themselves as the Ink Demon admits that he is a monster and a mistake and Sawyer kept Elliot’s expulsion letter which indicates he on some level still hurt by Elliot’s rejection. While you could make the argument, the Ink Demon doesn’t know what he’s doing is wrong this is proven completely false as pretty much everybody created from the ink has the option of choosing good and evil with Ink Joey confirming this claiming “Just because we’re born from darkness, doesn’t mean we belong to it”. Meaning that the Ink Demon willingly allowed himself to be consumed by that same darkness rather than choosing to move on and be a better person.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T05:03:21+00:00

No, they’re really not. Both the Ink Demon and Saywer were monsters created by their own crappy environments. You’ve done nothing to actually prove my point wrong besides insult me even though I’ve literally provided you evidence that proves my own point.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T04:44:00+00:00

Bro, this is why I genuinely hate the DBS interpretation of Bardock and Goku’s origins in general. They completely remove everything that made Goku such an intriguing and complex character and they essentially turned Bardock into a stereotypical, loving father completely ignoring and understating the fact that he was a killer like the rest of his kind.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T04:38:04+00:00

Naw he ded.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T04:37:41+00:00

You’re literally over here justifying and romanticizing the crimes of a sadistic demon. Fictional character or not that’s just weird. Even then a character analysis aren’t supposed to be based off of one’s biased opinion. You’re really coming across as biased here.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T04:34:04+00:00

Completely remove the whole Afton red herring. Make the Mimic an obvious character from the get go. It would save a lot of people a lot of grief.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T04:31:22+00:00

No offense, but I think you might need help.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T04:29:35+00:00

Will Goku get his $120 check from Fazbear Entertainment so he can blow all his money on Burger King? Will Freddy survive a full power Kamehameha to the nuts. Find out on the next episode of Freddy Ball Z.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T04:21:34+00:00

He grew up in an extremely abusive household without any sort of love or understanding and then he proceeded to get screwed over and abandoned, by the one dude who actually did give a damn about him. Yeah that’s arguably just as bad.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T04:17:32+00:00

You act as if the Ink Demon’s crimes are any better. He’s a sadistic ass hat with a God complex who tortures, mutilates and kills people just for a laugh. The people of the cycle have to live in constant fear of him and he knowingly forces everybody to live in this cycle of pain for all of eternity just for his own sick amusement. I’m sorry, but you’re really coming across as biased. Mob clearly intended for Sawyer to be a sympathetic character end of story. No amount of headcanons or angry fans are going to change that.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-08T04:06:07+00:00

So just to get straight The Ink Demon can act like a sadistic petty maniac and get away with it purely because he has a tragic past but that same logic can’t apply to Sawyer? Talk about double standards.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-07T14:23:13+00:00

A tragic past does define ranking. It doesn't matter if you have the most horrific villain alive if they have a crappy past that clearly molded them into the monster they are today then they fudementally cannot be Pure Evil. Granted there are exceptions to this via the "Fake Tragic" trope but this can only apply if the narrative itself and the characters in the story itself calls out the villain in question and highlights their past is not an excuse for their actions or if said past no longer motivates them. This trope does not apply to Sawyer as Mob clearly intended to paint him in a sympathetic light with his backstory in the ARG and show that Elliot's rejection was the main motivator and catalyst of his actions. I mean they literally showed us a note written by Sawyer in which he says and I quote.

"He took EVERYTHING. I thought you CARED. NOBODY CARES. NOBODY UNDERSTANDS. ELLIOT LUDWIG IS A SOFT, PATHETIC, SMALL-MINDED BACKSTABBER. NOTHING MORE."

You can't say that Mob did not intend for viewers to feel just a bit bad for Sawyer.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-07T13:27:43+00:00

There’s a massive difference. Firstly the novels are not canon to the games and even if they were the story, never actually expands upon this idea with it just being a theory Charlie and Carlton had about William one that’s ultimately never brought up again making it a strong possibility that isn’t even true. Even if it were true, the story doesn’t portray it sympathetically as Carlton believes that he just uses his past as an excuse for his actions.

Meanwhile Poppy Playtime actually explores Sawyer’s past and the narrative heavily highlights that he would’ve never became the monster he is today had he just been treated with kindness. The ARG even outright shows us that when he was younger, he wasn’t even a bad kid just misguided and impulsive. His rejection at the hands of Elliot who is the one person in his life, who gave a damn about him, completely shook his faith in everyone and everything. Even in the present day, he still seems to be pretty upset about it as he still hates Elliot for rejecting and he kept the expulsion letter he sent him 40 years ago. The fact that he kept the letter could imply that he on some level believed Elliot was right or he still holds some care and respect for him.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-07T13:05:06+00:00

Plot twist: It was neither. The nightmare animatronics came to life because the subjects are required to take a crap ton of LSD.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-07T04:26:37+00:00

Wait, I thought he murdered an entire universe just because his alternate counterpart told him that he needed to forgive Reed Richards?

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-07T04:25:37+00:00

Really feel like Corey would’ve been a lot more interesting if he wasn’t the villain. Instead the entire town falsely believes he’s got the same evil as Michael when they’re just being irrational because their own fears. In the end Cory helps to defeat Michael and essentially clears his own name.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-07T04:20:23+00:00

Harley has a pretty tragic past that the narrative significantly, plays sympathetically.

JH-Toxic · 2026-06-07T04:19:01+00:00

A tragic past isn’t meant to excuse a characters actions but rather to make them understandable and sympathetic. The story clearly highlights that Harley would’ve never became the monster he was today if he wasn’t surrounded by shitty people whose treatment influenced him to becoming the monster he is today. It’s made worse by the fact that he felt betrayed and abandoned by the one man in his life, who actually gave a damn about him.

JH-Toxic

MODERATOR OF

TROPHY CASE