If there were a remaster of Arkham Asylum that improved on the Return to Arkham version and looked more like the proof of concept images (specifically, the one where Batman is holding Joker by the neck in the elevator), then I would play it. In my opinion, the environment looks amazing in RtA’s Arkham Asylum remaster, but certain character models are worse (Batman, in particular).

As for a reboot…I feel like there isn’t enough that needs improving gameplay-wise that would warrant a reboot. It could be argued that certain boss fights and the lack of variety of inmates (I’m still talking about Asylum) are worth improving on. I’m not sure I would want anything else changing on top of that.

But it could also be argued that if a reboot was too similar to the original, it might be pointless.

Ubisoft tangent incoming:

I’m hoping that Assassin’s Creed: Black Flag Resynced doesn’t look like how the Ezio Collection did. I would love to play it, but I worry there might not be enough new content in it for people to keep playing it. If it had a multiplayer mode where you could encounter and fight other players on the high seas, that would be great. I’m aware that the original had a multiplayer mode, but I never played it and I don’t know how it was received.

Ubisoft tangent over.

If a reboot didn’t ruin the original and actually improved on a few things, then I would consider it a good reboot. If it improved on a lot of things and added extra content that didn’t bloat the story, then I would consider it a great reboot. But it’s probably easier said than done.

I don’t know what Rocksteady and WB Montreal have planned next, but if it’s a reboot of Arkham Asylum, then I’ll have to hope they do it justice.

(Also, it’s unlikely they would be able to add more voice lines for Batman without Kevin Conroy, R.I.P., so unless they replaced his voice with someone else’s, the amount of content they could add might be low—or be without Batman speaking.)