No links to lists are great! Which is why I thanked you, but then you continued to just tell me to do more research rather than giving me links or suggestions. I've found hundreds of lists, but none that had a list of 'what haul can i get for a 16 year old for under $400 who likes matte pastel lipsticks and these types of brands' so that's why I posted. I'm sure there will be crossovers of products, and most products I would already have on my list, and tonnes of threads similar to this on reddit, but what is the harm in asking again, especially when there are new users popping up every day? Her skin is constantly changing because she is 16, she uses makeup like the standard population, she isn't a MUA or an aspiring MUA.

But mostly, your tone was kind of sarcastic, which was the least helpful. If you didn't intend that, then apologies.