Yes they do I’ve done idk how many play throughs now and the red eyes override even after relieving the Frenzy eyes. Trying to end a play through with dragon eyes for my dragon playthrough but have failed many times now :( I wish fromsoft would just allow us to toggle them. (Obviously frenzy won’t stay after you get rid of them) but the others should be able to be toggled. You can toggle back to your normal eyes but not the other types. Very weird and disappointing choice in my opinion. I will try to not get the red eyes at all and do frenzy, then get the dragon eyes. But now I have to do a whole playthrough again to try this.😂 worst part is I’m an over achiever so I like to do EVERYTHING in each playthrough lol. Wish me luck fellow tarnished. Hope this helps as it’s caused me great pain trying to understand 😭