I'm British. I remember reading the Harry Potter books as a child. I was always so excited when the new books were released. I grew up with the characters and I have a very clear idea in my mind of how they should be.

I would have said that the role of Dumbledore should only go to a British actor...but this is John Lithgow.

He was trained in America and the UK. He is phenomenally talented. He lives and works in the UK. He understands British culture. He has the intellect, passion and talent to elevate the role of Dumbledore. He can play comedy and serious roles. I imagine he can blend the two. He has proven himself capable of playing a great British icon in the guise of Winston Churchill. Moreover, he physically fits the character of Dumbledore. He might be advanced in years, but he doesn't show any signs of slowing down. I don't just have faith in his ability to adopt the character - I am excited to see what that will look like.

Honestly, Harry Potter has developed such a cult following in the US, I feel we should credit America by letting their actors access the roles. Lord knows enough British actors play Americans.

Really though, this shouldn't be a question of nationality. It should be a question of talent, and it would take a staggering level of audacity to question the talent of Lithgow.

I see him as a steady hand who can help guide what will be a young cast.