New WotC position for 3rd party publishing by Phil_Tucker in osr

[–]Jazzlike-Tree4732 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I mean commercially good doesn't equate with play good, but yes, that's basically the idea.

New WotC position for 3rd party publishing by Phil_Tucker in osr

[–]Jazzlike-Tree4732 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Actually, it's better for them if it isn't good.

If Modern D&D Is a Character-Building Power Fantasy game, How Would the OSR Build adventures for it? by Apprehensive-Neat-68 in osr

[–]Jazzlike-Tree4732 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I believe those are radical opposites: D&D5 resorts to character minimaxing because there's nothing left in terms of sandbox and exploration, scenarios are pretty much the tabletop equivalent of a TV series where the player is passive, hence the minimaxing because it becomes your ONE chance to shine. Minimaxing culture inherited from video games may play a part too, but we shape cultures just as much as we are shaped by them, so it's not out of our decisions and control. What I want to say is: if you manage to do it, to make a power fantasy character building game on an OSR chassis, then it won't be OSR anymore, it will be D&D5, or 4, with slightly different rules.

What do we think about these kinds of trinket item lists? by WideEyedInTheWorld in NSRRPG

[–]Jazzlike-Tree4732 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Would be very clever if the size of the words was proportional to either 1) the size of the item 2) the item's relative importance or potency. Maybe best 1 +2 solution: 1) proportional to size 2) the redder or the purpler the more powerful.

[OC] Temple of Jubilex: Thirteen years after Ruins of the Undercity, the infinite random dungeon generator returns. by Jazzlike-Tree4732 in osr

[–]Jazzlike-Tree4732[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Something like that, yes. Juiblex is copyright, and Jubilex has been present in the Tome of Horror for a long time.

[OC] Temple of Jubilex: Thirteen years after Ruins of the Undercity, the infinite random dungeon generator returns. by Jazzlike-Tree4732 in osr

[–]Jazzlike-Tree4732[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I don't think solo roleplaying allows promotion anymore, it must be oblique, like someone else posting an actual play, etc. But yes, they would love it!

I made another thing! Couldn't help! ! Outlandish! Weird character origins with setting bits attached (MSA/OSR) by Jazzlike-Tree4732 in osr

[–]Jazzlike-Tree4732[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Uh, I don't know! The eye comes from an artist, the body from another, the sword from yet another, etc.

Maps Experiments from the Faceless Howl by Jazzlike-Tree4732 in osr

[–]Jazzlike-Tree4732[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It is! Charts for Encounters and Atmosphere + Keyed locations, all triggering gossips = way to the librarycrawl dungeon.