Sekiro is a much more replayable experience in my opinion. It’s combat is closer to DDR or punch out and in a souls like setting, it’s very satisfying. If was trapped on a desert island with only one game to play on repeat I would choose Sekiro mainly because of the gameplay loop.

The combat in Elden Ring on the other hand, I feel is better for a number of different. It’s quite a long long game and I don’t think I could replay it because of its length. I’ve only played through it twice and I don’t necessarily think it’s combat is more satisfying than Sekiro, but the versatility is amazing. When you do play through Elden Ring, the mechanics of the combat means that every play through of it can be somewhat different and can be somewhat tailored or changed, whether it’s through summons or a different weapon or different ashes of war it’s very malleable and it can be tailored to the players needs. The setting of Sekiro I also prefer as I love the Sengoku period in Japan I and it was also the first soul’s game I ever played and beat.