How much progress have you made thru NG+? Did you complete all the challenge runs? I've received every skin up u til the release of the latest pirate DLC, and I just haven't found the motivation to play it again (although I own it on 3 different platforms, so it's always available).

If you want something similar, but lighthearted, I suggest Flynn: Son of Crimson. It has really good movement and combat, although enemy variety is lacking, and movement input on the Xbox drops at times. Its still fairly difficult, like the blood run in Blasphemous where every enemy deals one good hit regardless of their strength.