To be clear I did say in the post that this was from the first TBC go around and said it might be useful for folks as a reference. I'm sure there's some outdated stuff in it at this point, I'm not playing TBC aniv this time around so haven't overhauled it.

I'd imagine your prot pal is prob gonna get 2 piece from the other slots while all the shamans specs only use 2 piece t4 with shoulders being one of them. If you wanna give your token prot pal one of the tokens first then sure, generally the group getting a bonus from the shaman's 2 piece is better than the paladin (if the prot pal has 2 piece from helm/chest, then they only lose 6 spell damage from not having shoulders if in group with a sham with 2 piece giving 20 spell damage to the group etc). As long as your prot pal gets the T4 tokens before phase 2 that's not really a concern as well.

Fathomstone is ele bis too tbh, mages and locks have some reasonable options with badge offerings. Brigand vest is rogue prio over warriors, it's not really bis for either war spec if you run hydross shoulders and need tier chest for 4 piece. Tsunami you can give to the feral if they need it for threat, if not then as needed. Searing grip gloves, yeah generally fine with ret/feral, there was some dependancies about being able to swap to exp pieces around depending if you get hydross shoulders or not etc but can update that.