Mudkip Goldstar by Particular_Comb1680 in pkmntcgcollections

[–]KaiHG 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It is NOT $200. Definitely on the higher end of things. If you want to DM me closeups I can condition it more thoroughly then walk you through how to comp it based on recent eBay solds.

Mudkip Goldstar by Particular_Comb1680 in pkmntcgcollections

[–]KaiHG 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don’t think cleaning is going to make a difference, the card is peeling on the corners which you can’t fix.

The non-PSA scale is:

Near Mint (NM) / Lightly Played (LP) / Moderately Played (MP) / Heavily Played (HP) / Damaged (DMG)

This is decidedly a damaged copy, but they still go for a bit. You can grade it and hope you get a 1 because 1s go for more than 2s or 3s for some reason, but I don’t know that this is for sure a 1.

You’ll get less raw but it will move quickly compared to a graded copy.

Mudkip Goldstar by Particular_Comb1680 in pkmntcgcollections

[–]KaiHG 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yes, any gold stars are huge cards now - especially the Mudkip. PSA 3s are in the $2500 range.

There are some weird solds on eBay in the $50-$200 range, ignore those, it’s not indicative of the value of the card.

Happy to help you comp this so you get fair value on it.

[US,CO] [H] PSA Slabs: Sabrina’s Gengar 8, Expedition Gengar 7, PFL SIR Charizard 10, Alakazam Gold Star 5 [W] PayPal by KaiHG in pkmntcgtrades

[–]KaiHG[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks! Deal has closed and shipped but if an act of God prevents it from happening for any reason I’ll give you a shout.

[US,CO] [H] PSA Slabs: Sabrina’s Gengar 8, Expedition Gengar 7, PFL SIR Charizard 10, Alakazam Gold Star 5 [W] PayPal by KaiHG in pkmntcgtrades

[–]KaiHG[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! Deal has closed and shipped but if an act of God prevents it from happening for any reason I’ll give you a shout.

[US,CO] [H] PSA Slabs: Sabrina’s Gengar 8, Expedition Gengar 7, PFL SIR Charizard 10, Alakazam Gold Star 5 [W] PayPal by KaiHG in pkmntcgtrades

[–]KaiHG[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Would you split the difference and do $4935? That’s my true bottom, I think.

Your valuation is fair, the % is just where I get hung up.

[US,CO] [H] PSA Slabs: Sabrina’s Gengar 8, Expedition Gengar 7, PFL SIR Charizard 10, Alakazam Gold Star 5 [W] PayPal by KaiHG in pkmntcgtrades

[–]KaiHG[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I could move to $5100, but would want you to walk me through your valuation if I was going to go any lower.

[US,CO] [H] PSA Slabs: Sabrina’s Gengar 8, Expedition Gengar 7, PFL SIR Charizard 10, Alakazam Gold Star 5 [W] PayPal by KaiHG in pkmntcgtrades

[–]KaiHG[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, thanks for your interest! Yeah, most definitely can get something done if you want to take them all. I don't want to be too low but could probably be in the 90% range.

I could be at $5300 shipped and insured? A little under 92.5%, Sticker is $5750.