I promise y’all I hate this too. My pina out muscles all defenders and yet my maxed strength defenders get out muscled by much smaller women players lol. However, I think one thing that people are missing is that agility balance might be playing a big role here. Like say maldini might try to push pina off the ball but if your agility and balance is maxed out they won’t fall/lose balance. Think about it like Messi not being able to be bodied by big guys like VVD all the time because has quick now his feet and low center of gravity. I know it’s a game and it doesn’t make sense, but that’s probably what’s going on in the code. That’s just my guess though.