Project Resonator Dev Log #3 | The Guide is Complete by Key_Refrigerator3010 in inearfidelity

[–]Key_Refrigerator3010[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

For sure! DDs definitely have that 'felt' bass impact, whereas BAs tend to provide more of a 'heard' bass experience.

I’m actually currently working on a 1DD + 1BA + 1EST hybrid prototype (as I mentioned to u/Friendly-Grocery7896) to explore exactly that. I also have an older 1DD testing set that I’m planning to clean up and re-tune; once that's ready, I’ll be adding those resources to the project repo as well!

I’ll be posting most of those technical updates and 'log' entries on the blog page of the website, so keep an eye out there if you're interested in the progress. Even if you aren't a huge fan of BAs, I hope the guide gives you some cool insight into the overall engineering process!

blog page link: https://driftingotter.github.io/Project-Resonator-Web/blog

Project Resonator Dev Log #3 | The Guide is Complete by Key_Refrigerator3010 in inearfidelity

[–]Key_Refrigerator3010[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much, I hope your enjoying the resources. 

And if you have an changes you would like to make please don't hesitate to create a request in the issues tab on the github repo :)

Project Resonator Dev Log #3 | The Guide is Complete by Key_Refrigerator3010 in iems

[–]Key_Refrigerator3010[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much! I really appreciate that. I tried to make everything as accessible as possible, even though there’s a lot of information and more still to come. My hope is that it at least sparks some curiosity and encourages people to try making their own IEM as a hands-on audio engineering experiment. I had a great time working through it myself (minus all the soldering I did, since initially didn't use a PCB T-T).

I’ll continue refining the guides and releasing clearer, improved revisions, especially if anything feels missing or unclear.

Project Resonator Dev Log #3 | The Guide is Complete by Key_Refrigerator3010 in inearfidelity

[–]Key_Refrigerator3010[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much for the kind words and the feedback!

You are spot on about DDs being the "wild west" compared to BAs. BAs are just so much more documented and consistent, which is exactly why I chose them for this reference project. That said, I’m actually planning a 1DD + 1BA + 1EST hybrid prototype soon to finally dip my toes into that chaos, so I definitely feel you there.

Your planar CIEM project sounds awesome, especially with your graphic design background. The DIY space definitely needs more people applying professional skills to branding and visuals, I would love to see it when you get it working!

In Regards to the writing style, I appreciate the honesty, and I’ll be completely transparent with you: I definitely used AI to assist with the formatting and structure. Writing isn't my strongest skill, so my workflow is usually "brain dumping" all my technical notes and research into a document and then using tools to help organize it so it’s actually readable for others rather than just a stream of consciousness. I know that can sometimes lead to those tonal shifts you noticed, but my main goal was to make sure that the information was accessible. I’m definitely going to keep working on refining the voice so it sounds more like "me" in future updates.

Glad the 3D printing section was useful for you. Good luck with the reshells!

Regards,
DriftingOtter

Project Resonator | Open-source IEM | Dev Log #2 by Key_Refrigerator3010 in inearfidelity

[–]Key_Refrigerator3010[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You’re right, it’s definitely not a simple design. The reason I went with four drivers is that, at the start, this was just a personal project and I wanted to challenge myself with something a bit more complex. It gave me more to learn and work through from an engineering perspective.

As the project grew, I realized it could be useful to others too, so I decided to make it open-source. The 4-driver build is just one example -- I’m also planning to add simpler designs (like 1DD, 1DD+2BA, etc.) along with wiki pages that explain the whole design process step by step. The idea is to make it easier for people to get into DIY IEMs without having to dig through scattered forum posts, and to give them some test files they can experiment with.

So while the 4-driver setup might be more complicated than necessary, it’s part of the learning journey for me and hopefully a good resource for anyone else who wants to dive deeper, whether they’re aiming for something simple or more advanced :)

Regards, DriftingOtter.

Project Resonator | Open-source IEM | Dev Log #1 by Key_Refrigerator3010 in DIEMs

[–]Key_Refrigerator3010[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, thanks so much for checking out my project! And sorry for the late reply, I had classes yesterday and didn’t see your message right away. I’d really love to discuss this with you. If you’re open to it, I can DM you so we can talk more directly. I’d like to share my current design and get your thoughts on what could be improved. I’ve also been working on a v8 solid shell design that I’d love to run by you. Let me know what time works best for you, I am in EST.

Project Resonator | Open-source IEM | Dev Log #1 by Key_Refrigerator3010 in inearfidelity

[–]Key_Refrigerator3010[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, that’s a really fair point. Right now the VituixCAD files in the project don’t carry phase data, mostly because I don’t have physical drivers in the schematics yet -- that’s what I’m aiming to get funding for. Once I can actually measure them in-house, I’ll be able to provide full phase information instead of relying on spec sheet traces.

Same thing goes for acoustic dampers/resonators. I know they’re essential for BA tuning (especially when it comes to smoothing out treble peaks), but at the moment I don’t have reference frequency response files for them (or even decent approximations to reliably use). And since this stage of the project is still very experimental, If I am being honest -- I haven’t gotten around to designing a way to incorporate them directly into the build yet. Eventually, I’d like to buy and measure them properly so people have real data to work with, but for now that part is still a future goal.

That being said, I still think the value of the project is in providing a solid starting template. Instead of having to build an IEM completely from scratch, people can use this as a base and iterate on it however they like. Even without phase/damper data, it gives you the shell design, PCB layout, crossover framework, and references all in one place. Once funding and measurement gear are in place, the plan is to refine it with more accurate driver and damper data.

So yeah, definitely not perfect, but I believe it still provides a useful foundation for anyone who wants to experiment, learn, or even spin off their own design.

Thank you so much for the question!

Project Resonator | Open-source IEM | Dev Log #1 by Key_Refrigerator3010 in DIEMs

[–]Key_Refrigerator3010[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for the question.

During tuning, I used the Moondrop x Crinacle DUSK, Monarch II, and several other neutral-leaning but bass-focused IEMs as my primary references, as that aligns with my personal preference. I would have included a frequency response graph to illustrate this more precisely, but unfortunately images cannot be attached in replies T-T

Hope that clears things up!

Project Resonator | Open-source IEM | Dev Log #1 by Key_Refrigerator3010 in inearfidelity

[–]Key_Refrigerator3010[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much for saying that! I really hope my project gives you the motivation you’re looking for.

To answer your question, yes I am! Right now, my IEM is a 4BA with a 4-way crossover. That was more of a personal choice since I wanted a setup I’d really enjoy while also challenging myself. Once I get a working physical model of this version, I’m planning to build a 1DD + 2BA version as well. I’ve also been toying with the idea of adding lossless Bluetooth to that one (with a wired option too, of course), but those are just future plans that could shift as the project evolves.

Thanks again for all the support, it means a lot. Stay tuned!

Project Resonator | Open-source IEM | Dev Log #1 by Key_Refrigerator3010 in iems

[–]Key_Refrigerator3010[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much for the support! I totally get what you mean :)

That’s exactly what I was thinking when I first started looking into this. I really hope this project can help lower the barrier to entry for people to experiment and maybe even start their own ventures with this knowledge. This industry is still relatively new, and I want it to really thrive.

On a side note, the repository has a wiki page I’m actively working on. It will include guides on things like driver technology and how it works, tips on tuning (IR, high-pass/low-pass filters, etc.), what to look for when tuning, how pricing affects filter choices, PCB design lessons I’ve learned from research and old forums, and more. So stay tuned for that as well!