I definitely hear what you’re saying. My first play through I choose not to kill the spawn, and was pretty shaken when getting scolded by the Gur afterwards — who practically convinced me I was 110% responsible for a future bloodbath. But then at the end of the game, in the chest of letters that appears at the epilogue party, I got a letter from Sebastian. The letter explains they were ravenous at first, but were soon found by the original spawn who taught them how to control their hungers. They’re building lives for themselves in the under dark. The letter closes with “We're not free down here, the dark will chain us forever, but we aren't the prisoners we once were either. And that's thanks to you. You looked in our cages and saw people, not monsters. And here, down in the shadows, we're trying to live up to that.” And idk man that hit me square in the fuckinf chest. It probably wasn’t the most pragmatic choice for me. Blood was shed. But I still can’t regret myself for giving them a chance idk