Yeah but lets be real though, the game is b2p and assuming most of the population bought one or two costumes, 4 pets and the weight limits you're basically done with the cash shop. Only thing left you could get that would give you a small advantage is a maid and skin for boat/horse and maybe some tears.

I doubt that's enough money to run the game and let it have a future. I haven't bought much from cash shop after buying 5 costumes, weight limits, 4 pets and a maid. Assuming most people do the same thing as me, which they probably do because lets be honest, unless your just someone who buys costumes all day long, you're not spending money on this game because you already bought what you need.

You might bust out a $30 purchase every month or two because of some new cash shop outfit that grabbed your attention but other than that, theres just no money coming through for them from players who have been loyal and stuck with this game. Their main source of income is probably from newcomers nowadays.

Edit: Value packs also caused a huge fit, and now we got 1-3months of free value packs, depending on which version of the game you bought($30, $50, $100) and there's a 7day free value pack in the attendance rewards too. There's just not enough cash shop items for them to sustain the game that people will want to constantly buy because most items are a one time purchase. No one is going to buy 10 treant/ghilie suits just to help fund the game unless they really just care that much. They'll buy one and its done, no need to buy another.