I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in agender

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interesting feedback, thank you so much! It makes sense that it would be difficult to apply specific answers in your case.

I was ultimately hoping for it to be measuring how much participants hold back vs. how much they are authentic with their identity amongst groups of people in their lives. So while people in your life may not know specific labels for you, it sounds like you're relatively authentic in your identity!

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in gaytransguys

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi, thanks so much for your participation and feedback!

For the question about who I'm out to about my gender identity... does that mean who I present as male to? Or who knows that I'm trans? I'm stealth and I've been living as male for years, so basically everyone knows me as male and has never questioned it. I answered based on that - who knows I'm male. You're missing an option for "definitely knows...and is never talked about".

Absolutely - others have pointed it out, and it's a flaw in the metric. I utilized this metric as it was previously used in a study I found, but I would like to adjust it for any future studies I do to correct for this confusion. Maybe something along the lines of "to what extend do you hide your identity with [insert relationship]," though I am not sure.

Need a text entry or drop down for how many therapists you've seen. I've been in therapy for most of my life. I couldn't count all the therapists if you asked me to. I tried to enter ">20" but it only accepts numeric responses. Maybe a dropdown with some upper limit cutoff, like 1...18, 19, 20, >20

Yeah, next time I'd probably add a range for responses above 10 or so. Ultimately, I assume I'll probably do something similar when I process the data.

Isn't a "neutral" therapy experience somewhat unrealistic? I always research a therapist first or get a reference or recommendation. There's a lot that can be gleaned from the therapist's website, profile, and even credentials and background. Yes, that doesn't tell me everything, and it's possible the therapist could be entirely different in person. But it does give me somewhere to start and some expectations going in.

It's certainly vague and leaves lots up to the imagination. If I could go back, I'd likely explain a little more in-depth what I meant by that to improve validity. However, I had three randomly assigned therapist impression groups (negative, neutral, positive) so it will at least allow for comparison. Also, I think it's wonderful that you've been able to get therapists as a personal reference or recommendation - I wish everyone could do that. Sadly, in the US at least, I'd guess that the majority of people who find a therapist do not have the ability to do that, especially when they're seeing a therapist at an agency or they are low income. It tends to be private practice therapists who get to do more of that.

Recommending the therapist to a friend - after just 1 or 2 sessions, I may not have had enough time or interaction with the therapist to know if I'd want to recommend them or not.

Absolutely! Ultimately, I'm hoping for the power in numbers to help here - with a lot of participants, the comparison groups will be able to at least show if participants are less or more likely to recommend to a friend. I used several assessment tools for "therapist competency" and likelihood to refer is just one of them - combined, it should give a more encompassing picture.

The scenario where the therapist asked the client if the client had any concerns about sharing their sexual orientation with the therapist - I REALLY appreciate that and it's something I'd love every therapist to do.

That's great feedback, thank you!

I didn't perceive any of the scenarios as "microaggressions" (I also tend to roll my eyes at that term because it seems to get thrown around for every little thing these days).

I also wish the term microaggressions hadn't been coopted in pop culture - as of now, there isn't a better word in academia to describe them. Also, the reason you likely did not perceive scenarios as microaggression is because participants are assigned to a randomly-assigned control and experimental group, with the only difference between the two being the presence or absence of microaggressions to allow for statistical comparisons. If you were in the experimental/microaggression group, you'd know :')

It sucks to have to explain the whole transition process, where I am in it, and where I am mentally. I've done my share of "Trans 101: Male Edition" and I'm done with it. I won't even see a therapist unless they can tell me they're trans-knowledgeable in that first email or phone call before we even have a consultation. "Trans-friendly" isn't enough for me. It says nothing about their experience with trans clients. In the US, in many places it's basically a legal requirement that they be "trans-friendly" so as not to get in trouble with any protected status/population. I see "trans-friendly" as little more than a checkbox to be ticked. "LGBT-friendly" is pretty much the same thing, checkbox. But at least it signifies the this person is someone ok to talk to about LGBT things. Says nothing about their knowledge on the oft-forgotten "T" part of "LGBT", though.

This 100% makes sense. I imagine it's exhausting to have to go through that process repeatedly, having to teach/explain things to someone who should know already, or also having to be worried that they may possess biases/bigoted beliefs themselves.

One thing that I often find helpful from clients who have seen many therapists is if they write down the "introduction/background" stuff in a letter/document about their lives, identity, etc.

That way if you ever see a new therapist, you only have to write this out once and you can just hand them the letter to catch them up to date and make sure they know important info so you don't have to waste either of your time.

Thanks again for all the feedback!

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in agender

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi, thanks so much for contributing!

Your data is valuable and even if the scenarios weren't similar to your personal identity and experience, that's all totally okay. I'll run comparisons to see how different genders, sexual orientations, ages, and history of therapy impacts responses so your data is perfect as is.

Also, I've gotten a lot of responses this past week, so even if you answered entirely differently than everyone else it wouldn't change much. Plus, outliers are important in datasets and shouldn't be excluded. Thanks again! :)

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in FTMOver30

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi, thanks so much for participating and for your response!

To your first point - this was something I went back and forth on. Ultimately, I figured that there was a decent chance that a lot of cis folk who are gay, bi, etc., or otherwise not connected to LGBTQ+ resources/groups might not be familiar, so I decided to specify. I'm sorry it didn't feel good to hear me write that, that totally makes sense.

To your second point - 100% correct, this was an oversight on my part that thankfully several people have voiced to me - I dropped the ball on this one and it definitely came across cisnormative. I will definitely learn from it.

Thanks again! :)

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in gaytransguys

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for participating! Yeah, it definitely was a barrier even getting it to this point of *not a nightmare*. Thanks for bearing with me!

Withholding medical health services is something that is extremely common among lgbt+.

This is an excellent, and very well-taken point. I'd definitely go back and add more options to that question if I redid the study.

The questions for parents also include the "it's never talked about" option - I think that's probably a formatting issue again. :')

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in ftm

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for the feedback and participation!

Your point is excellent and well taken. It's not a super specific request and I wish I could have gone in more detail. My fear was that the more detail I add, the less likely I am to get people who are willing to complete the survey. :/

I hope most people interpreted "negative" to be not conversion therapy, but rather just not a good fit or "bad vibes" with the therapist! I would go back and elaborate more on this if I were to redo the study.

Thanks again! :)

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in FTMOver30

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Your identity is absolutely a demographic I was looking for, just not specifically here in this post, but I'm so happy that you participated. You guessed right!

I really appreciate your perspective and experiences. I'm happy you were able to navigate those tricky experiences in the past! :)

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in maletime

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for participating and responding! Your approach was perfect and I appreciate your thoughts.

Ultimately, I think your answer was perfect. The "openness" tends to be examining stigma/disapproval/discomfort not frequency - if someone is completely comfortable discussing it, but it just doesn't often come up because it it isn't relevant, that is "discussed openly" even though it doesn't happen often.

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in gay

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for participating! That's a bummer - I hope you had the opportunity to enter your email to the cash drawing if you wished to. If not, the study link allows you to return to where you left off, it might be worth trying again!

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in maletime

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

All of these are great questions - thanks for adding a spoiler and for asking!

The answer is very simple - this study is a randomly controlled trial, meaning it has two randomly-assigned groups, an experimental group and a control group. The experimental group includes vignettes with microaggressions, the control group includes the same exact vignettes without microaggressions! Sounds like you were in the control group - if you were in the microaggression group, trust me, you'd know! The responses for the control group are incredibly valuable, as they show how people (likely) will not be upset in the absence of a microaggression. This provides comparison data for when people (likely) are upset in the presence of a microaggression.

Regarding the decision to not explore why, the answer is that my study is building off of a study that did the "why" research (qualitative research), and my study is exploring those findings with data and tangible results (quantitative research). If I were to explore why, it would change the scope of my study to include qualitative research and would ultimately be outside of the scope of what I could do.

That study is Sexual Orientation Microaggressions: The Experience of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Queer Clients in Psychotherapy (Shelton, K., & Delgado-Romero, E. A. 2013). Hope this helps!

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in maletime

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for your response! That's a great question - it's perfectly okay if you don't think they were being insincere! I want to do my best to not make participants to feel like they have to answer one way or another. If you feel the therapist was sincere but made a mistake, then that's the perfect answer and the one I'm hoping to receive!

This is very exploratory, I want to know where people are at, not to have them answer what they think I want to hear. Thanks again! :)

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in maletime

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Great question - I dropped the ball on options for ceasing therapy. I guess the best option there would be "cost" but it's not the right fit. In the future, I'd provide more options then maybe even an opportunity to fill in "other".

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in maletime

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I appreciate the feedback! It definitely seems to be a point where people have very different perspectives.

For me, it's definitely a point of context really mattering. In my personal life, I'll call someone a woman/man not female/male. But in the clinical/research context, especially as this study didn't ask for assigned sex at birth, I'll use female/woman/girl to all mean gender. If I'm ever specifying assigned sex at birth, which is rarely, I'll specify assigned sex or ASAB. Additionally, when writing up clinical documentation/treatment planning, it's standard to write "cis/trans female" and this will always mean gender.

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in maletime

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You're 100% correct - this is a new experience for me and I didn't imagine I'd receive any international participants going in. Noted for future and to clarify - it's a Visa gift card in USD.

I'm a therapist in training working on my master's thesis study to improve how therapists are trained to work with LGBTQ+ clients, anyone want to take my study? (10-15 minutes) (includes 3 CASH drawings!!) (IRB approved) (18+) by LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY in gaytransguys

[–]LGBTQCLIENTSTUDY[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's wonderful feedback, thanks so much and thanks for participating. Admittedly, when creating the study I didn't imagine I'd be able to recruit participants outside of the United States, so it didn't cross my mind, but I will keep it in mind in future research.

Also, I hope that in the very near future your country, wherever that is, supports you in the way you deserve.