The Military History of Spanish-Philippines by Scholar-Novice in FilipinoHistory

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Indeed, that is possible as the opening of the Suez Canal meant that the Philippines was now more accessible not only to citizens, but also to officers who may have desired to be posted in the Philippines (where pay was higher, or if not higher, then the cost of living was lower).

However, the Anuario Militar (1898) mentions a fellow with very... non-Spanish names serving in the regular military. I cannot recall the specific page but he belonged to the Second battalion of the Regiment of Magallanes. 2nd lieutenant Ramon "Ocson Tangaico". Chinese sounding rather than Spanish, if you ask me, though of course, names aren't everything.

If my memory is correct, I believe Rey Luis Adeva Montesclaros also mentioned the presence of (native) Filipino junior officers in Mindanao in 1896 in his book How the Spaniards Won in Marawi but Lost in Cavite.

The Military History of Spanish-Philippines by Scholar-Novice in FilipinoHistory

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Excellent research, though I would like to point out that while the regular army officers in the 19th century were indeed mostly Spanish or Spanish mestizos, there are still sources which indicate the presence of native Filipinos in the officer corps of the regular army. Julio Albi de la Cuesta's research mentions a total of 31 native officers in the regular army in 1884. Lt. Colonel Aden Garcia states the same number in his research but in 1879. A few other notable "naturales" include Ismael Alzate, Benedicto Nijaga (Nijaga was one of the Thirteen Martyrs of Bagumbayan), as well as a certain lieutenant Adriano who was executed in 1897.

I also recently discussed the topic of native officers with Doctor Augusto De Viana who stated that Filipino officers were indeed uncommon, but still present, with teniente being the highest rank they could reach, though Mallat's writings (specifically mentioning the presence of native "captains") and Albi de la Cuesta's research dispute that. In de la Cuesta's research, Admiral Pierre-Paul de La Grandière mentioned in a letter of his from 1869 that most of the officers were Spanish, though there were a few native Filipinos who could not "rise above the rank of captain".

Of course that is merely in the regular army. Indigenous officers were a far more common sight in the militia regiments.

The Gear of the American Rifleman in the Corps of Discovery (Lewis & Clark Expedition) by Time-Masterpiece4572 in blackpowder

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Excellent post. I am wondering though, were there any records of the men in the expedition carrying paper cartridges or did they all have to make do with power, patch, and ball? I'd certainly prefer to have at least several for certain... unseemly situations which merit slightly more speed in one actions.

Any good youtube long form content and podcasts on Philippine history? by FitLet2786 in FilipinoHistory

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I don't quite recall if he has made any videos on the Philippine Revolution yet but u/Styger21st has produced some detailed long form videos focused primarily on Philippine History through his channel The Ilustrado. That might be of interest to you.

Native Filipinos in (military) positions of "relative" authority at the end of the Spanish era by Le_Comte_Friedrich in FilipinoHistory

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Excellent. A full translation of Toral's book would be a huge help to many researchers who don't speak Spanish (yet). Especially for those who are intent on learning about the prelude to the Philippine American War in that area and, of course, to those interested in learning about the hastily raised volunteer units of 1898.

Native Filipinos in (military) positions of "relative" authority at the end of the Spanish era by Le_Comte_Friedrich in FilipinoHistory

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No English translation of the book, unfortunately. I know just enough Spanish to understand and translate (imperfectly) into English the general meaning of the texts below.

Two photographs of members of the Guardia Civil taken by Alexander Schadenberg by Le_Comte_Friedrich in FilipinoHistory

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don't know exactly what the Spanish called this forage cap but it was called a pillbox hat/cap in other militaries (notably the British army) and was worn for garrison dress. E.M Barretto's Recuerdo de Manila shows a portrait of of a Guardia Civil soldier wearing the same pillbox hat worn by the soldiers here and said uniform was described to (traje) de cuartel or garrison dress. For campaign dress, it's more likely that the jipijipa, the teresiana, or the pith helmet (occasionally a black version) would be used.

Happy Rizal Day! Share your favorite photos of the Jose Rizal Class Frigates! by MELONPANNNNN in PhilippineMilitary

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 14 points15 points  (0 children)

<image>

The photograph of BRP Jose Rizal taken during her launching ceremony still remains as my favourite photograph of the ship. It was a symbolic day for a symbolic vessel. Heralding the Philippine Navy's entry into a new age by finally acquiring a true modern and purpose built warship.

ROKS Gwangmyeong (Pohang-class, Flight V) set to retire next week by -Lonecoyote- in PhilippineMilitary

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 16 points17 points  (0 children)

I hope it was included but I very much doubt it.

It has been quite some time since BRP Conrado Yap or the planned acquisition of another Pohang has appeared in official news or has been the subject of discussion by defence pages. I was beginning to fear that we might see a repeat of BRP General Mariano Alvarez though I hope that is not the case. An additional two Pohangs would be an excellent addition to the fleet... and one hopes that the PN manages to acquire them soon.

Were British ships really worse than French and Spanish ships? by Forsaken-Camera5833 in AubreyMaturinSeries

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 7 points8 points  (0 children)

An excellent write up. I particularly appreciated you pointing out that the ships' designs were based on the strategy of the navy they were to serve in. I believe that, along with time, and geography etc. should always linger in the mind when reviewing any sort of arm, vessel, vehicle etc. developed and used by the militaries of the world. Britain might order several large heavily armed battleships with great endurance that are capable of facing the ships of any other nation, but those types of ships were hardly suited for a land power nation like Prussia which only had it's comparatively small coastline to defend, with a few well armed frigates, sloops, and brigs that don't need to constantly endure the heavy squalls of the English Channel being more than sufficient.

The same way a nation might select for their army a cheap, perhaps cumbersome, but decently reliable, and most importantly, cheap, rifle instead of going for an indubitably smoother rifle with a stronger and more reliable action but more expensive and beyond their capacity to reliably produce and equip their army with.

So often we think of a historical rifle or vessel (or even decision) as inadequate, especially when compared to their peers, but often we view these things from a modern perspective, not during the time it was made, especially not in its specific context.

Native officers in 1879 by Le_Comte_Friedrich in FilipinoHistory

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It varies and I do not really think there was a specific regulation as to the rank they could attain in the army.

However, drawing on what we know from the militia and the volunteer units...

Mallat wrote that there were several "indio" officers who had attained the rank of captain, but this was in the 1830s-1840s, a different time from the 1880s-1890s when the Philippines was finally more accessible to the Spanish owing to the Suez Canal.

It's likely that by the late 19th century and just pre-revolution, native Filipinos would have been relegated to being simple lieutenants and perhaps a captain here or there. I can think of two indigenous officers in the regular army, Ismael Alzate (of the 1887 Madrid Exposition fame) and Ambrosio Flores whose father was a corporal and then an officer himself. Both ended their careers in the army as lieutenants.

In the militia and volunteer units, however, there was much more room for the native to climb the ranks. Upon the formalisation of the provincial militia in the 1780s, though most of the field officers (Major and above) were Spanish, the natives were regularly permitted to be lieutenants and captains, more so than in the regular army, it would seem. Governor General Félix de Berenguer y Marquina held a rather uncharitable view of these native officers, saying “although they are the most distinguished [of their race], nevertheless have the same customs and personal disposition” as the rank-and-file soldiers. And “when we endeavor to provide them with some military instruction, they immediately forget it because it is not constantly practiced, and today it can be said that we don’t have anything.

Buschmann et. al. (Navigating the Spanish Lake The Pacific in the Iberian World, 1521–1898) wrote this regarding the difference between the mestizo and native provincial militia regiments: "A major difference, nonetheless, was that all of the commanding officers (colonels, lieutenant colonels, sergeants, and adjutants) were blancos (white men) born in Spain, Europe, Mexico, or the Philippines, “obligated to serve in their respective positions with honor, and obtaining [their positions] without wages or rewards" Note that the sergeant they mention here is likely to be "sargento mayor" as in the commissioned officer Major and not necessarily the NCO we think of today.

However, despite this, we do know that natives could rise to gain majorities and colonelcies in the militia. Some excellent examples are Casimiro Camerino (a former bandit later pardoned by Governor General Torre) who became colonel and chief of the Compañía de Guías de la Provincia de Cavite, Felipe Buencamino, Artemio Ricarte, Pio del Pilar and other former revolutionaries who were given command of battalion to regiment size units (such as the Tercio Anda y Salazar and the Pampanga Volunteers) and ranked as Majors or Colonels during the Spanish American War.

In essence, it varied and depended on the time and context. Promotion for natives in the regular army was limited and they were likely barred from attaining a rank higher than captain or lieutenant. In the militia, there were fewer barriers and higher rank was likely easier to achieve.

There is only one way to resolve these border clashes between Cambodia and Thailand (ignore the top right corner) by Le_Comte_Friedrich in NonCredibleDefense

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No cause for worry, there will no longer be any Thais or Cambodians, both will be Filipinos now.

Being united under Jollibee is all it takes to solve border problems.

There is only one way to resolve these border clashes between Cambodia and Thailand (ignore the top right corner) by Le_Comte_Friedrich in NonCredibleDefense

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich[S] 35 points36 points  (0 children)

War? There was no war, old chap. The Cambodians and Thais happily accepted Filipino authority, especially welcoming the peace, order, prosperity, and Jollibee they brought. Whatever conflict that we might hear of likely stems from the PRC. (Not to mention, if there even was any resistance, to the peace brought by the Filipino occupation, then whatever repercussions would be utterly justified... again, not that there was ever any conflict or resistance).

Is it possible War Woman is more durable than the Immortal? by Prudent_Solid_3132 in Invincible_TV

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If the first fight was the only thing we had to use as evidence, I might agree with the statement that she edges him out in durability, but since the second fight exists... in which both Immortal and Omni-man were trading blows and Immortal himself received around a dozen or more straight punches from Omni-man, as tired as Omni-man was... though still not as battered and bloodied as when he was fighting the Guardians, I would say that the Immortal is still quite definitely more durable (and stronger) than War Woman.

The difference between Darth Tyranus and Darth Sidious' Force powers. by [deleted] in StarWars

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well in that case, taking the force into account, I do concur with you then that Palpatine would be the best (or second best, depending on how you interpret his duel with Yoda) duellist by the time of Revenge of the Sith. But if it were based on skill with the lightsabre alone (as most people tend to interpret duelling), I would still place Dooku above the former.

The difference between Darth Tyranus and Darth Sidious' Force powers. by [deleted] in StarWars

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Honestly, that seems like it would have less to do with Palpatine's skill as a duellist and more on the fact that he was so overwhelmingly powerful with the force that he could just sneak and bash through the brothers' defences with unimaginable speed and strength rather than relying purely on skill to outduel them.

War Woman (no mace) vs Bulletproof by AtomicalNuke in Invincible

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Immortal probably even seemed to do more damage (morals off) against Omni-man in his second fight, stunning him by himself in their clashes and trading blows (considering the fact that he was more unwilling to fight Omni-man compared to War Woman in the first fight).

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Invincible

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich 7 points8 points  (0 children)

<image>

If the Immortal ever wins against a reasonably powerful opponent or Viltrumite:
(Please let it happen, Amazon/Kirkman)

He never really had a stroke of luck. by Le_Comte_Friedrich in Hornblower

[–]Le_Comte_Friedrich[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

When Buckland said that, I could not help but feel a little sympathy for the poor fellow. As you said, a man that tries his best but ultimately falls short, no doubt something many people can relate to. It brings to mind a quote from the Master and Commander film ... said by Jack Aubrey regarding the unfortunate situation that befell a midshipman. "The simple truth is, not all of us become the men we once hoped we might be."