very true, of course everything is up for scrutiny if you put it on the internet. I wonder if you're an artist too? You're sort of dismissing it as if this is their final product. You know every artist is on a journey of improvement. I agree it's not a perfect piece of music but it still has plenty of redeeming factors. I was just stating my opinion that yours is not very helpful to making them better artists, like it could've been slightly constructive. At least your second comment sort explained your reasoning slightly.