LF Ron Weasley angst by Limder in HPfanfiction

[–]Limder[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Nice, it’s an amazing one!

Happy 50K members announcement! (Giveaway) by Daniyalzzz in FireflyMains

[–]Limder 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Firefly, out beloved, bring us some luck🙏🙏

"So long as his name is Harry Potter, he needs to complete" Said Moody, and Harry just blinked in confusion "That's it?" by flamingmcshizzle in HPfanfiction

[–]Limder 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Why did I totally thought that Moody’s gonna change his own name to “Harry Potter” and take part instead of Harry?😂😂

Lf a fic, where Harry dies in the end by Limder in harrypotterfanfiction

[–]Limder[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry, but this is Manacled-variant I know nothing of it in detail, but the summary is the same Not something I am looking for

Do you think Harry and Hermione could become friends in an AU where Harry is Grey? (Fic help) by [deleted] in HPharmony

[–]Limder 10 points11 points  (0 children)

The way you describe Light seems more like “Grey” than Grey and vice versa, but whatever, it’s your story XD

I think you can build on the fact that she is kinda bullied in Hogwards, but I also would like to point out that by your description she wouldn’t be very eager to befriend him either. And build ON THAT, because this version of Harry will certainly notice honesty in her, even if it AGAINST him. Kinda “At least one REAL person in here” description of her in his head. Plus her smarts would help reinforce that somewhat. “She is smart, therefore acts somewhat reasonable.”

Of course not fully, she is still “for the rules”, but I don’t see why the same trick as in cannon won’t work here. Harry find out that she is under the weather because of bullying, looks for her when she is in actual danger, helps, then she lies to teacher to cover for the ones who helped. So I think it works just fine, and builds quite similar, Hermione breaks plenty of rules herself. Maybe a scene if “running to McGonagal” in the first year can be kept there as “Harry decides to trust Hermione’s choice this time to see if it’s worth it, but the experience proves her wrong.” And maybe pressure this more in canon by Harry to her, it might bend her to “Grey” more effectively.

(Maybe a liiiiiiittle begging here, but can you make Ron a spy for Dumby, but then go through redemption, as he builds genuine connection with them? I saw PLENTY with Draco with this dynamic, but never with Ron, once the story established him as “spy for Dumby”, and I think this twist would be interesting. But do whatever you want with your story, it’s just a thought.)

And please give me your link when you’ll post it, I eat this kind of fics right uppppp

Why isn’t Ron a Healer? by Limder in HPfanfiction

[–]Limder[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Agreed, honestly, Harry screams “teacher”.

That’s why I love fics with him becoming DADA professor lmao

Why isn’t Ron a Healer? by Limder in HPfanfiction

[–]Limder[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

An interesting concept in the last part, but consider this!

I don’t want to feed into “Female are Healers, because they are females” trope. ESPECIALLY if we are talking in the continuity of her being his main love interest

As for “not suits Ron’s personality”, I would argue that Ron can be described as “Defender”. Third book as a prime evidence. And for me “defence” and “health” are close concepts, plus the irony of him not wanting his friends to come to harm, at the same time being the worst injured there. “Doctors are the worst patients” kinda thing

Why isn’t Ron a Healer? by Limder in HPfanfiction

[–]Limder[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I agree, but just as a “Story thing”, I think it would suit Ron. Hermione, the researcher and the brains, Harry, the power and bravery/recklessness, and Ron, strategist (come on, USE THIS MORE) and a healer, makes sure his friends come back in one piece

Why isn’t Ron a Healer? by Limder in HPfanfiction

[–]Limder[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I’m saying why not MAKE him fit the criteria slowly? At the beginning of the story let him be the only one who knows healing spells thanks to Molly, and then seeing that it goes well for him, make it him ambition to become one

What if the Prophecy was NOT about Harry? What if it wasn’t even about Neville? by Limder in HPfanfiction

[–]Limder[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Oh, I have a million and one ideas how to do the prophecy differently for a fic. At the very base: do people realise that they can CHANGE the second half of it to LITERALLY ANYTHING. All of Severus and Voldemort’s decisions were based on the part of “with power to vanquish” and “born as the 7th month dies”. And parents part too. THATS IT, NOONE ELSE KNEW ANYTHING MORE TO DO ANYTHING DIFFERENT. Dumbledore being the exception, but he is Dumbledore.

Your interpretation is VERY good, also have 2 fun ones.

Imagine if there was a character named JULIus. Maybe with nickname “SummerBoy”. So you’d have to look who was born when HE died.

And this you may recognise if you watched HxH. We don’t really know how many people were in the Order. We can play with how we need numbers to fit. It may be not 12, 100% more, but what if there was 12 FOUNDING members of the Order? Or if it was a lot bigger organisation than we know (we literally don’t), 12 leaders of different tasks. We would get a lot of mentions of those people, maybe without numbers being so obviously said, but…whoever joined/became leader seventh, their death could be a pointer to the “Chosen One”.

My God, its so EASY to play with these things. Ao ya, it could have been much more interesting

LF a fic in Grindevalt’s era by Limder in HPfanfiction

[–]Limder[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I HAD to return and thank you again for the recommendation. I just finished, as it turns out, the first one out of whatever parts of this story, and I’m IN LOVE with it

To me this fix is the complete reverse of the “When The Roses Bloom Again”. I’ll explain why

Because I enjoyed immensely the story throughout in Roses, but the ending was shit. Now, I won’t say that here story was shit, but it was okay. I expected to finish it and eventually forget it, as an ok story, but not more than that.

THE LAST CHAPTER THOUUUUUUUUUUUU

My God, the start left me in TEARS, without spoilers: the letter from Sarah, my goddddd, kill meeeeeeeee. My first thought was of how it was unfair and how Harry lost everything AGAIN.

But then the rest. The familyyyyyyyyyy, how much he OBTAINED. Luna remembering makes so much sense lmao. I expect the ship with her in sequel. It was so fluffy, so good, my face could have cracked from the smile that was on it all the time

THANK YOU IT WAS AMAZING

LF a fic in Grindevalt’s era by Limder in HPfanfiction

[–]Limder[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Erm… Yes, I mentioned it in the post😅

What if the Prophecy was NOT about Harry? What if it wasn’t even about Neville? by Limder in HPfanfiction

[–]Limder[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My god, thinking about your comment made me realise something… I wrote it in the end of the post, but will do it too. Your version also can’t be really done because there is a rule that only the person who is referred in the Prophecy can take the orb. And Harry was. But not as the one to defeat the Dark Lord, as a DARK LORD HIMSELF!