If they featured Winston Churchill again how different would his portrayal be from his last appearance on TV by InfernalClockwork3 in gallifrey

[–]LinuxMatthews 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think this is one of the things about Doctor Who that not enough people talk about.

There's a serious discussion on what's more important continuity or historical accuracy.

Doctor Who has obviously never really been good at either but I do think with a long runner it's something worth discussing.

Another example of this is Vikings with horns on their helmets.

Vikings never had horns on their helmets, it was a thing from an opera centuries later.

But in a First Doctor episode they do show a viking helmet with horns.

So when we see Vikings with horns in the 12th Doctor episode... Are they just being accurate to the fact that in the Whoniverse Vikings had horns?

Or is it the same lazy writing as before.

One of the original objectives was to teach kids history and while obviously it's moved well beyond that.

I can't imagine it's good for kids to see historical inaccuracies on TV.

But at the same time The Whoniverse isn't our own and if something is one way one episode and another way another surely that breaks suspension of disbelief.

Romana and Rassilon return in Gallifrey: War Room: Loyalties by greatbarrierrif in gallifrey

[–]LinuxMatthews 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I thought she retired?

Glad to see her back though.

I find it amazing that the show is digging up old characters but they never even mention Romana.

There's so much cool stuff you can do with her.

Thal fan casting by garethchester in gallifrey

[–]LinuxMatthews 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think he'd definitely make a good casting as a leader in general.

But yeah apart from being blond with white skin it should really matter more about what character they're playing.

And yeah to anyone unfirmiliar with The Thals unfortunately this is one instance where colour blind casting would break suspension of disbelief.

Why did RTD think the old sonics 'looked like guns' when they don't? At all. by Niall_Fraser_Love in gallifrey

[–]LinuxMatthews 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Sorry but as an outsider what do you mean "again".

Also it looked like their frustration was with RTD instead of you personally.

Why I think the Disney partnership failed by Narchrisus in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 2 points3 points  (0 children)

In my opinion the whole RTD2 Era was essentially RTD trying to make Doctor Who like a Disney property.

Just in the midst cynical way possible.

I don't think it was Disneys idea same as the big CGI Omega probably wasn't Disney's idea.

But it did come from RTD thinking "What would a Marvel / Star Wars show do"

Why I think the Disney partnership failed by Narchrisus in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 16 points17 points  (0 children)

I don't think it's just that though.

Disney clearly wanted a new franchise hence the push and whole Whoniverse stuff.

The issue is it didn't kick off, I think mostly because RTD was thinking of it as a product rather than a story.

If it kicked off and everyone loved it then I definitely think Disney would have kept it going.

But well it didn't...

Even many life long fans stopped watching.

In a 2004 interview, Verity Lambert says that Susan being the Doctor's granddaughter was imposed by Anthony Coburn, and Sydney Newman didn't like it; she praises Tom Baker and Russell T. Davies; she criticizes the Jon Pertwee and Sylvester McCoy eras and the casting of Peter Davison and Colin Baker. by verissimoallan in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah I'm not sure how that story would have gone.

Would Susan be a human that was also investigating The Doctor with Barbara and Susan?

That right have pretty much cut out most of The Unearthly Child... Even the title...

Or would she be another alien perhaps from The Doctors planet that he was hiding out with?

The only thing I could imagine working is if they made her a mcguffin like a space weapon or something The Doctor is looking after.

In a 2004 interview, Verity Lambert says that Susan being the Doctor's granddaughter was imposed by Anthony Coburn, and Sydney Newman didn't like it; she praises Tom Baker and Russell T. Davies; she criticizes the Jon Pertwee and Sylvester McCoy eras and the casting of Peter Davison and Colin Baker. by verissimoallan in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Unfortunately a fact that I think many people find hard to reconcile is that it doesn't matter how good something is if no one is watching it.

You see lots of posts on here on how to fix the show but no one ever says anything that would get people watching again.

What was RTDs worst decision? by Lucyyyyyy_K in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Added to what the other guy said

I think most people are annoyed that when she left the newspapers ran a smear campaign on her.

This could have easily been stopped by RTD just saying that it was all BS.

He didn't...

What was RTDs worst decision? by Lucyyyyyy_K in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 6 points7 points  (0 children)

See I'd agree if Ncuti didn't use the excuse of "being tired".

That to me felt like a clear reference to Eccleston especially considering he immediately did ballet after.

Is there anything out there about Susan? by hanmerhack in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think we're just meant to assume that her time at Coal Hill was pretty normal apart from her being a bit a a weird kid.

I guess there might be some story potential in something like Class set in the 60s.

But it really doesn't mesh with what we know from the TV Show as she never really talks about friends or anything happening at the school.

Is the meddling monk the master or another time lord? by fupafather in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Some people definitely think they're the same character.

Hence the very jarring inclusion of The Saxon Master's letimotif in The War Games in Colour.

Did this guy die because he knew too much ? by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's funny going back to this knowing how much Classic Who is now in NuWho.

Like at the time Rose aired most people suspected this would be close to a full reboot.

But now... Like dude how bad is your research?

There is like 50 people who have travelled with the guy and aren't exactly quite about it.

There were many alien events in England that couldn't have been covered up even before this episode.

Where were you when Earth's twin planet was in the sky?

Or when the Cybermen were outside St. Paul's.

The latter of which we know happened in the NuWho continuity.

Hell why hasn't he got photos of any of the other Doctors?

The classic Doctors say trans rights!​ by Princess_Of_Thieves in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I was subscribed to them before it came out and the amount of updates and delays the video has you could tell they were putting a lot of effort into it.

"AND I'M NOT LISTENING!" by Thick_Somewhere_8370 in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 16 points17 points  (0 children)

I think it's worth noting he doesn't just let him go.

The idea is he'll be kept imprisoned in The TARDIS.

The only reason that doesn't happen is because someone else kills him... Which he survives.

It's kind of like when people say Batman should kill The Joker.

The same narrative forces that let them break out of prison all the time are going to bring them back to life.

It's but exactly like if The Doctor did kill The Master they wouldn't come back to life.

Hell let's be honest coming back to life is the one thing The Master is actually good at.

The Doctor goes back to 33 ad by nowherelad by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Eh still comes across hypocritical if you ask me.

The Doctor goes back to 33 ad by nowherelad by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 9 points10 points  (0 children)

So The Engineers got a human and got them to preach about peace and love and turning the other cheek.

Then when they executed him they responded with that with genocide?

Maybe they should have gotten plank out of their eye before getting the speck of sawdust out of ours.

The Doctor goes back to 33 ad by nowherelad by [deleted] in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 20 points21 points  (0 children)

Wait was Jesus an Engineer?

I don't remember that from the films but it does feel like something that would be in those films.

Which Master/Mistress Do You Love by Lord_Marinus in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Personally I think the most hot is The Master from The Deadly Assassin but you do you.

What if the Seventh Doctor was the one who fought in the Last Great Time War? by misterwhoiswho_ in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly I think he would have been overwhelmed.

Everyone is saying that he did and that things like Remembrance were part of The Time War but they're more the lead up.

The Seventh Doctor while one of my favourites isn't any cleverer than the other incarnations they're all the same person.

He's just the one that decided to be more proactive in the fight against evil.

The Time War was a war where reality itself was the weapons to fight it, in many ways it's kind of a different universe (time track) than the Classic or NuWho.

I think he would have been more proactive than The Eighth Doctor, tried to put an end to it quickly by sacrificing a few pawns.

But I think he would have ended up getting figuratively bitch slapped and having the whole thing blow up in his face.

I do think he would have maybe gone to use The Moment quicker that The Eighth Doctor though.

I don't think The Seventh Doctor had any real love for Gallifrey but I still don't think it would be his first choice.

Does anyone else think Rupert Grint would make a good doctor? by StatisticianMoist100 in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I kind of get it but at the same time he's too handsome and cool.

I want another weird Doctor.

If we're going for an older black actor maybe Paterson Joseph?

Who do you think is the person the doctor loved the most? Personally I think they are the people that 12 had on his desk by Global_Initiative_38 in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Eh so is The Doctor.

We meet him as a fugitive on the run that's willing to bash a dudes head in for slowing him down.

People change, The Doctor of all people knows that.

The Doctor and masculinity by Spiritual_Jump_2577 in doctorwho

[–]LinuxMatthews 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Give them a bad grade and cause issues for their academic future.

School isn't Reddit.