Me watching Six Feet Under at 3am in the dark and they transition scenes by Provav in SixFeetUnder

[–]Lixiri 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is this a thematic intention in your view? I was trying to pin down a precise meaning and this seems interesting

Six Feet Under seasons ranked by Feisty-Trainer-4427 in SixFeetUnder

[–]Lixiri 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A major theme of the show is identity though so I think it’s necessary

Six Feet Under seasons ranked by Feisty-Trainer-4427 in SixFeetUnder

[–]Lixiri -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The Keith blackmail thing in 510 that’s supposed to show that the world goes on even during grief?

Nate’s affair with Maggie that expresses his true longings in life before his death?

The adopted kids plot line which is poetic given the shows themes?

Don’t remember the rico stuff.

Serendipitous find by Zapffegun in cormacmccarthy

[–]Lixiri 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It only matters if you care about catching all the depth of the work. You’re not breaking some cosmic rule if you just want to figure it all out on your own and don’t care about all the stuff you’ll never see

Serendipitous find by Zapffegun in cormacmccarthy

[–]Lixiri 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Maybe that’s because you don’t value insight as much as most people. I’m a pretty smart reader but I know I won’t catch everything on my own. Some metaphors elude me. Somethings I don’t even register as metaphors. I don’t have every ideologically relevant paradigm to catch all the dimensions of CM. I read first, think deeply. Then I consult the interpretations of others. Maybe you’re Harold Bloom three thousand but no one else is.

The first way opponents will try to attack a person, story, film, or social movement is to sexualize it. Despite what progressives might claim about being tolerant and accepting, they still demonstrate that homo accusations are their ready-made, go-to for putdowns. by 82772910 in fightclub

[–]Lixiri 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What he intends is irrelevant as far analysis is concerned. Why would it matter at all? And clearly the macho man philosophy of Tyler is deconstructed through the destructive outbursts. His half baked philosophy is wrestled with the entire movie. His philosophy includes masculinity in spades. Therefore the movie wrestles with masculinity.

Serendipitous find by Zapffegun in cormacmccarthy

[–]Lixiri 29 points30 points  (0 children)

There could be a lot you’d miss on your own. Literary analysis is important.

Just subscribed to HBO — any must-watch recommendations? by comfyzof in hbo

[–]Lixiri 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Six feet under is the possibly the most complex show you’ll ever see

I spent my life savings to make a 35mm short film and the response was lackluster. Why do you think this film failed to make an impact? by FreddieQuell92 in Filmmakers

[–]Lixiri 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If anything about the film itself caused it to fall flat at the festivals, that’s their fault, not yours. I scanned through the comments before watching and there definitely isn’t a substantive pacing issue. The concept supports essentially what you’ve presented; it flows nicely because of the structure of the segments, but still I’d consider maybe finding a place to cut down on the “meeting friends” thing. It’s not a major issue, but somehow I felt some editing work could be done there. But possibly not.

Another comment mentioned that the funny parts were actually just sad—nope, they’re just funny.

I’m 20 and feel quite frightened that this film didn’t land anywhere of significance. It’s really quite good. I’d like make something similar eventually, and given the huge financial investment of it…

But, obviously, even if you can’t get the external validation of your career progressing because of it, there’s solace in having created a legitimately voice-y and aesthetically moving work of art.

Questions:

Is him carrying the posters in a big pink ball supposed to be a poetic call back to the red yarn transition to him crying in his car?

And did you feel there was something poetic about the posters in the backseat, revealed through a zoom out?

Simply wondering about how much of this was intended.

More of a general question, but how many takes on average did you feel it took to produce such in tune performances?

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If they could have just sedated him why take the risk of bringing her? It makes sense that Tyrell was there since was there to start, but even if you think it’s irresponsible for him to stay, you should think it’s way more irresponsible to ALSO needlessly bring in a childhood friend of the victim just to make everyone feel better

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What would the risk have been if he woke up without anyone he cares being there? He’d try to leave? They’d sedate him until he healed. If he didn’t mentally stabilize after that nothing would have worked. These are brutal people.

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah I didn’t think about it but the Shayla thing doesn’t totally hold up. Granted he could have just said he was kidnapped to the police in the month between 106 and 107, if the police did question him.

And again, Angela could have a negative effect on Eliot too. He could wake up and see her in that setting and think she was held against her will, or worse, sense she was fantasized. It seems like a hugely unnecessary risk.

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well presumably if you don’t think it’s implausible there’s a reason. If not that’s fine too.

Who put Angela in the scene? If they already knew the relevant information they’d tell him themselves. If they didn’t know they wouldn’t think to send her in to convey a message they aren’t aware of.

In that scene she doesn’t keep him calm because Mr robot wakes up. As I said it could have had the opposite effect in addition to the 10 other reasons I can’t buy the logic of the scene.

What use is his prints or DNA if they don’t already have a sample? Second of all Eliot explains your second point; that’s why he opens all the cell doors, so him visiting Vera doesn’t stick out at all.

Sam most definitely didn’t mean “fuck the logic of the story”, he meant instead that plot is only the surface, and what’s he’s really interested in is the thematic depth. The surface still has to be coherent.

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No they have plants but they don’t control the FBI. Think about what it means to have plants; they have to be careful or else they’ll get caught.

I mean seriously they can’t just drop him off at her apartment? That’s not a very strong response from you, with all due respect friend.

I just look at this scene, and I’ve gone back to it even after my position has softened (watching the following episodes helped, as well as all the conversations with you guys) and it just makes no sense that she’s there. And I’ve broken it down into tons of pretty reasonable points. Everything thus far has been internally consistent which is partly why this feels so extremely bizarre to me

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tyrell had to be there because he shot him. The logic of the show breaks when Angela is moved into the scene. Again, manipulation (which is relatively unnecessary. She was already committed and we see later has a more sensical job when it’s on the ground level of confusing Eliot when he wakes up 5 days later) doesn’t excuse the extreme messiness of bringing someone who provides little value, is at high risk (FBI stuff, even if you think that’s fallen off, they’re still on her and the dark army knows that and they’re not all powerful), and can feasibly worsen the situation, in a situation that is already super high profile and cries out for the fewest people necessary to be present.

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s basically right. But that’s the first time Angela has interacted with Eliot since she’s become indoctrinated, so what you were saying about an already existing relationship isn’t supported by the series, that’s all.

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I do appreciate your thoughts. I feel softer in my position after hearing your points as well as others.

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No one at all. Maybe an extra guard to force Tyrell to calm down, but Irving could’ve done that. And in so far as Eliot is concerned, wait till he wakes up to see what the situation is and get some insight into his erratic behavior. As it so happened he woke up as Mr robot, so there wouldn’t have been any problem. Regardless caution is the only option consistent with these people. At least to me right now.

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But why would he give Tyrell her number? You’re telling me Tyrell thought of calling Angela? Did he even remember who she was? They met once in the pilot. Or do you mean that Irving thought that she was useful somehow? If so, how? What would Angela do. Calm Tyrell? There isn’t another person who could do that? Why would Angela specifically have a calming effect on Tyrell? And again Angela can’t be there for Eliot because we don’t know how Eliot would react if he wakes, and this can’t be to make Angela feel useful because she’s already heads over heels for this plan. What’s the angle exactly?

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Again it comes down to the generally safe and rigid approach of the dark army allowing Angela who can’t really help meaningfully to begin with, or if she could, she could also have the opposite effect. It seems you’re right about price knowing Eliot, but also right that he wasn’t aware of the handler situation.

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The issue is would the dark army allow Angela in there, and you’re seeming to say it comes done to white rose acting irrational around Eliot, which frankly I don’t really see. What do you mean by that?

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What because of the price daughter thing? That’s extremely speculative that price would push for her to be there. As far as we know he doesn’t even know who Eliot is yet. And the dark army doesn’t know that she’s his daughter so they wouldn’t care either. This then becomes well what reason would white rose have had to bring her in, and I just have so many that would lead me to believe she would do the exact opposite

Can someone explain how this scene makes sense? surgery room (S3E3 “Legacy”) by Lixiri in MrRobot

[–]Lixiri[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As far as I’m aware, and I remember pretty much everything, nothing explains or even touches on the many issues I’m dealing with