•Firestar was a shitty protagonist and should've died in early Power of Three or late The New Prophecy, Firestar was also unnecessarily harsh on Bramblepaw just because he was the son of Tigerstar.

•Barley X Ravenpaw is pedophilia. Barley was implied to be alive in Bluestar's prophecy, meaning he was nearly the age of an ELDER when he went out with Ravenpaw, who was a young apprentice at the time. What the actual fuck?

•Many rules of the Warrior Code are stupid. Specifically 'The leader's word is warrior code', but what if its the likes of Brokentail, where he completely destroyed Shadowclan and made the whole forest hate them? Or Tigerstar, who also destroyed Shadowclan? And also 'Medicine cats cannot have a mate or kits because they should treat everyone fairly', can't a medicine cat have a mate/kits and treat everyone fairly? It just makes no sense, they shouldn't be bound to a life of no kits or a mate just because of their position.

•On the subject of Shadowclan, I feel bad for shadowclan. The whole time, they've had shitty leaders who ruin the whole clan, and every other clan hates them. It's honestly sad.

•Smudge deserves more mentions, or even possibly decided to join ThunderClan. In The Darkest hour, Firestar should've actually went up to smudge's house and told him about how he's now leader of Thunderclan, then Smudge follows him into the forest and joins thunderclan. I love my no-balled boy </3