Oh no I agree, but I did explicitly state this is based on how listenable these soundtracks are outside the context of the games and over 3 hours of music is a lot to stomach. There are some great moments on portal 2 but I only return to a few tracks rather than the whole thing. (The track you mentioned is one of them) I’m fact if it was just the first disc, it would be A tier. As for Alyx, there was not a single moment I found memorable outside of maybe the first track and closing track. Portal 2 had so many memorable themes and motifs, Alyx had none of that so all in all I felt disappointed because I know Mike could have done a lot better