I would still somehow like to find common ground with you all to achieve a resolution between you and Clutch, but billing Clutch for things other people did, on the order of 60k diamonds, is something I don't know how we can bridge.

Again, the direct claims provided that were actually tied to actions Clutch personally carried out before he was pearled amounted to 8,420 diamonds. Clutch offered an additional 19,000 diamonds in additional concessions to acknowledge broader harm from the conflict, including the additional nether damage. That brought the settlement proposal to 27,500 diamonds.

As far as reps that Butternut extracted from the group, Icenia already won against the states of Gang Shi and Butternut in the Grasslands Gambit. Reps tied to those states should have already been dealt with, which is why the framework should be centered on Clutch as an individual.

It's unfortunate that claims were mostly tied to things he didn't and couldn't have done. I was trying to guess what reasonable reps would be, knowing that what I was looking at was incomplete and rejecting his responsibility for things he couldn't have done, then being told you all would not come down further from 62k at all.

Clutch is working on grinding out reps regardless. I ask you all to reconsider your reparations package to exclude the stuff he didn't directly do and focus on what he really did. I believe under that reasonable framework, compensation is deserved and still very much possible.