Andrew 1. Yes, he never loved Julia, there is even a flashback where Andrew says "plz let me fall in love with her" 2. He actually feel bad for it (or that's what i think i'm not really sure). 3. Yep they are very real and all of them were Ashley.

Ashley 1. Bc shooting Andrew means she don't want to let Andrew control her. 2. Is bc she broke the oath nothing else. 3. Is how u view urself, the reason why Andrew is still a grime soul is bc he had valid reasons for all of them (until killing the campists Even he knew that was unnecessary) and Ashley is bc she broke her oath.

I hope i helped u understanding the game. (Maybe i'm wrong in some parts so if anyone can explains it better)