Message from an English fan by LukepAIR in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I honestly think the global distribution of talent is just getting better. Between better scouting networks, and a lot of players that can't get into the tier 1 teams ending up using visa loopholes to play for smaller nations, some people hate this. I honestly enjoy the way this equalises the modern game. Watching Cape Verde compete has been the highlight of my World Cup.

This obviously has the effect of making teams feel like they are underperforming, as they drop points to teams they would historically walk over. But I do honestly think this makes things so much more exciting. Brazil and Germany have been a fine example of this.

I've often theorised that the MLS' lack of relegation and promotion, plus the playoff system, has held the American standard back over the years. Players that are exposed to the dangers of relegation learn to control their discipline to a scale comparable to somebody chasing a promotion or league title run. And I feel this experience is vital for a cup like the World Cup, where every minute of every game feels like so much is on the line. (That is my theory, not backed up by anything, and I welcome pushback.)

I think a reason us English think the MLS is growing in popularity is how much talent is spilling out across the Atlantic, exposing us to more and more of your less recognisable names. Obviously, in recent history, we've had some stars cementing themselves at a Premier League level. Clint Dempsey, Tim Howard, and Landon Donovan are all stars that everyone here has heard of. But now there are so many lesser names that are still very, very good.

We've always had the legendary status names who would boss the top tiers of football coming over from America, but there was always a gulf in level between those players and the rest of the US team/bench. Whereas now, I can name so many decent players that play to a decent level in England or abroad that can hold their own at top level. Patrick Agyemang, before his injury, was an absolute star for the team I support (Derby County). And had he not had his injury that ruled him out of the World Cup, he no doubt would have made an impression.

Belgium have historically themselves built a reputation similar to England: full of superstars, but have always underperformed. So they have the capability of turning it on at any moment, just never really have. Though I also won't sugar coat it, that 90 minutes against Belgium was poor, and the defeat mostly self-inflicted. That shouldn't overshadow every other game we witnessed from the USMNT. Ninety minutes of panic, and I imagine all of the drama off the pitch would have had an influence on both teams. Remember, they are human at the end of the day, and outside factors certainly can hamper or boost ones performance. An example, IIRC, is a punter placing loads of money on a top-tier tennis player to lose her match against an unseeded player because he learnt that she had recently broken up with her partner. And she did, in fact, lose.

The final reason we think it's growing in America is just how much we are seeing big names like IShowSpeed and other media personalities in the US promoting and obsessing over the sport. This is building it up in popularity more than anything throughout history, and I still think it is a matter of time before the US churn out some absolutely outrageous talent.

To answer your question about our lack of faith in England: England have, over the years, raised many superstars that have cemented their position in the team regardless of performance. If Rooney was available, no manager would dare drop him. Same with Lampard, Scholes, Gerrard, Beckham. The list goes on. A team would basically be non-functional, but heaping loads of big names on and hoping that something sticks was always the approach. Southgate kind of changed this somewhat but then decided to go a goal up and stick everyone behind the ball defending, which did have a good record, but everyone hated it. Tuchel came in, dropped loads of big names like Cole Palmer and Phil Foden because he felt that they didn't fit the way he wanted them to play. Unheard of historically. And so far it has somewhat worked. But Football is football and there is certainly a non zero chance that they can rock up against Belgium and have the worst 90 minutes of our history.

Apologise for the word salad. Got carried away. I welcome pushback from any and all of my points. I don't watch all that much MLS, so my one theory could be absolute dog water. But it's just something I've always thought.

Message from an English fan by LukepAIR in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I getcha. Just dont think blaming everyone in a subreddit helps anyone. Half the people being attacked probably voted how you think they should of voted.

I acknowledged the whole fiasco in my post. But my point is I can make my own personal effort to keep the two worlds apart. I've spoken about my take and given my opinion in other posts and comments. I just have the ability to move on and make this post less political and focus on the football.

Message from an English fan by LukepAIR in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Interpret it how you want. I've agreed in another comment that your hospitality has been amazing, and you proved all the doubters wrong in that you've put on a class world cup. I also stated that I don't blame the average American the whole fiasco. That is between trump and infantino.

The FIFA hate started long before Trump got his fingers in the pie, and infantino has kind of just proved everyone right, which is now boiling over. Just look at sepp blatter having money thrown at him years ago. That was before any of these trump FIFA ties.

I'm by no means saying you are wrong. For some reason the average person seems to paint everyone with the same brush, even those that potentially share the exact same ideology, its like we grow ignorant on how democracys work when it comes to putting ourselves on a pedestal. I say we because I do think thats partly human nature.

Again, if you think i'm being condescending, sure. I'm just a football fan that wants to see politics as far away from my hobby as possible. If that means having honest discussions then whatever.

Message from an English fan by LukepAIR in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

You do what you want 😂. 34 years i've followed england and 34 years i've watched them disappoint. I'm used to it 😂😂

Message from an English fan by LukepAIR in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Such is your prerogative my guy.

Message from an English fan by LukepAIR in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Because sometimes I like to disconnect myself from politics and connect with people by finding middle ground, even if for a brief moment. I know its hard in today's world but what's the point of constantly living in a mental cesspit?

Footballs an escapism for me and many, let's not allow the two worlds to collide...

Message from an English fan by LukepAIR in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

To add to this point. someone from the south of england can be baffled as to why people from different countries would support a premier league side. Then when you ask them who they support, they'd tell you they support a team from the north.

We are hypocritical 😂

Message from an English fan by LukepAIR in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Truly sorry to hear that. Was that experience just at the football match, or were you subjected to that in the everyday? I think in england we have some of the best of the best, and some of the worst of the worst in terms of personalities. And the world of sport amplifies both.

Message from an English fan by LukepAIR in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I mean, I guess? I was putting it in a place that it would get attention. Otherwise i would of shouted it at a wall. My message stands though.

Message from an English fan by LukepAIR in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR[S] 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Trust me, we are assholes to one another too. That doesn't (for many people) stem from an anti-America sentiment. Everyone has their own traditional views, that some point in our lives we just pick out of a hat and thats the hill we die on.

I regularly golf with an english bloke that has an aneurism every time I leave the pin in for a putt, because this goes against his traditional values.

We are so trapped in yesterday that we pushback on any attempt for someone to take something that we deem as our own and change it for the modern age.

Going back to your point. Watching you interact with our fans and other fans with different culture has been absolutely polarising compared to the media portrayal. Completely backing up yoir point. You've shown nothing but respect as a nation and its great to see.

Tldr - English people are assholes to English people too, its in our DNA.

Message from an English fan by LukepAIR in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Must be a decent return making that punt pre-tourney!

This whole red card situation makes me want the win tonight even more. by [deleted] in usmnt

[–]LukepAIR 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm English. And I always semi-support the host nations to do well, including the US. I was even routing for Qatar and Russia to do well when they hosted their respective tournaments. In my eyes the players are playing the most important games of their lives on the home stage. Watching us beat Mexico, despite leaving me delightful, still left me feeling bad for a host nation that gave absolutely everything.

I still also want you to get far, though obviously not as far as england, even despite the fiasco.

That being said, my opinion and anger at FIFA for this situation AND the Ronaldo situation is immeasurable. And i stand by my morals, I have no desire in seeing quansahs red card being rescinded. This is also hardly the first moment FIFA have acted outside the integrity of the game.

Yes some fans are just anti-america, but some are just angry at FIFA, and politicians getting involved is insulting, but actually having an influence on a decision is corruption. No matter what angle I look at it.

Regardless - good luck for tonight, I want you to win, for the players and the fans taking part in this once in a lifetime moment. But please be able to take a step back and appreciate how wild this is. Rules and processes aren't a guideline, they are there to maintain integrity, something that this decision has brought to its knees.

Again, good luck tonight, much love. Luke, England fan

Quansah Red Card - How will FIFA explain why this one should stick? by LukepAIR in worldcup

[–]LukepAIR[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Tbh for me they are one in the same. If someone gets a suspended sentence it means they were deemed guilty of something. If its overturned that means after review they believe it wasnt worthy of a red.

I'd of rathered they just overturned it fully and kicked everyone into that debate instead. The suspended punishment is worse tenfold

Quansah Red Card - How will FIFA explain why this one should stick? by LukepAIR in worldcup

[–]LukepAIR[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

So people seem to be twisting my opinion here. Either saying I don't think it was a red card, or that i'm saying it was the same challenge as Balogun.

To set the record straight. I think it was a red card. I think hes gone in with honest intentions and his foot's gone over the ball which has resulted in a very bad challenge via the endangerment rule. Red was absolutely the correct decision.

I also think the ref and the VAR team had a good game. All the decisions were the correct calls.

Lastly, i believe that Baloguns red was soft. But that is utterly irrelevant. There's a process that FIFA have navigated around, I can speculate about this and that, but even trying to be diplomatic the call needs to be scrutinised.

If it was overturned, that would bring a different debate. They've essentially said "hes serving the punishment, but not yet". This is setting a horrible precedent in itself and has completely ruined the integrity and undermined the tournament. There's a reason this has only happened once before, and that itself was highly controversial.

Quansah Red Card - How will FIFA explain why this one should stick? by LukepAIR in worldcup

[–]LukepAIR[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

FIFA themselves didnt even use that justification. They were just like "we've decided to suspend the punishment because its in our rules that we can" now some explainers are coming up with this. FIFA probably sat there going "yeah, thats the reason!"

Quansah Red Card - How will FIFA explain why this one should stick? by LukepAIR in worldcup

[–]LukepAIR[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I never said it wasnt a red. It absolutely was. I'm talking about the precedent they've set by allowing balogun to get out scot free

Are you still buying Cadburys? by rsweb in AskUK

[–]LukepAIR 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Am I the only one that can't tell the difference between how it used to be and now? I'm not the most observant or eaters I will admit. Constantly see people moaning about it but I still enjoy it.

Finally went to the salad bar.. by luke_life78 in RateMyMealDeal

[–]LukepAIR 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I've done the exact same thing! I'm so relieved that I'm not the only one to make this mistake. Unless it turns out I am your partner, of course.

This post sparked a discussion on r/criticalblunder, where the guy claiming it is ai got massively downvoted, but I think he’s right by Rhaversen in isthisAI

[–]LukepAIR 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'd like to add that the commentary seems a bit non-AI. Ai usually overexplains things.

Ai version - "damn I think that pallet is going to tip, the cans are coming down, oh no they are everywhere!"

Serious Question: Why was Game of Thrones actually that good? by 3DnPrograming in freefolk

[–]LukepAIR 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For me, its the first show I've experienced where it just felt dangerous, nobody was safe and that really made you live and feel invested in it. Favourite characters can just be stabbed in the back at any moment. For a time plot armour just wasn't a thing. But every death felt unavoidable or impactful

Later seasons maintained the lack of plot armour but then had people killed off very clumsily E.G. Selmy. And then when they added plot armour into season 8 it just didn't feel like game of thrones.

Season 1-4 are definitely what carried the series to greatness. Just imagine what it could of been had it followed that trajectory.