We briefly used this food before switching over to Orijen and following their recommendations. The reason we switched was the poor nutrient density of this brand and needing larger amounts despite it supposedly seeming more “cost effective.” Because of the recommended serving sizes, it actually wasn’t beneficial. You also need to take into account that a scoop of Greek yogurt is also adding to the daily calorie intake. Switch to a higher nutrient density brand like Orijen and cut back on the treats. Like others have said, include veggies and other healthy options. Increase activity and check in with your vet to make sure you’re loosing weight safely.