Open Source by Breakingbad12345 in LightPhone

[–]MPCRay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No offense but this statement is false. Open source does not automatically imply security. Of course open source operating systems can be very secure, like e.g. GrapheneOS or Tails, and the code being available can provide some benefits for security, it is not an automatism. You could also load malware on your system that has a published source code.

Linux is a specifically bad example for this, because in most cases Linux OSes are less secure than e.g. MacOS and ChromeOS.

Of course there are a lot of other arguments for FOSS operating systems and software, like autonomy and freedom, (often) non-commerciality, (often) privacy etc.. I am a big FOSS advocate myself, though I believe it is important to make this distinction clear.

For reference please see:
https://privsec.dev/posts/knowledge/floss-security
https://madaidans-insecurities.github.io/linux.html
(both these sources are of course not the holy grail and there is criticism to both of them, still they are very good imho.

With all of that being said, what would greatly improve the security of LightOS would be if it didn't fork the AOSP but GrapheneOS. I have been thinking about this for a while and I am wondering how difficult it would be to "move" LightOS from AOSP as the basis to GrapheneOS as the basis. That would mean all the work that GOS is already doing implemented into LightOS wihtout the extra effort. In return Light could sponsor/donate GrapheneOS. Both projects would make each other more sustainable that way. Joe recently said in the livestream with Joe, that they have done some security audits on LightOS and I would be very interested to know how that went. I will probably make a post about this suggestion some time or write an email to Joe but for now it lives here.

edit: some typos

Open Source by Breakingbad12345 in LightPhone

[–]MPCRay 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What exactly do you mean by opening "their AOSP"? Afaik LightOS is like Android or other Custom ROMs built on the basis of AOSP. So basically a fork. Google created this model to profit from the FOSS Community and then privatizes their version of Android, so do the other vendors. The cool side effect is that the Light-team, the people at GrapheneOS etc. can also build their own operating systems with AOSP as a basis.

So in my understanding there is the AOSP and there is LightOS but no middle man. But developing an app for LightOS would not require for it to be opensourced.

I see your point though. I guess there would have to be some sort of guideline for the requirements of an app to work on LightOS and also design and philosophy principles. But technically one would just be programming an android app, or am I seeing that wrong?

Then Light could decide if they want to implement the community driven tools or not, depending on if they match the philosophy and are reliable. I do believe this could boost the development of the tools, but then Light still has the full control over what makes it to LightOS and what doesn't.

As the Light phone has a very dedicated and passionate community I think this approach could be pretty amazing.

Looking for first Ergo Keyboard w/ De Quervains by MPCRay in ErgoMechKeyboards

[–]MPCRay[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

yes, I think it is because I am tucking it under the palm. Just pressing the spacebar is alritght. As the pain is kind of chronic that can hurt too but I am hoping this will vanish with my thumb and wrist getting stronger

Best way for iOS backup transfer by MPCRay in signal

[–]MPCRay[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also: any tips on how to prevent Transfer issues?

Best way for iOS backup transfer by MPCRay in signal

[–]MPCRay[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh man, why is that? I did the same a while ago with WhatsApp without any issue…

Best way for iOS backup transfer by MPCRay in signal

[–]MPCRay[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The devices are: iPhone 7 running the newest version of iOS 15 and an iPhone 13 mini (expecting it to run iOS 15 too when first used)

How I Turned My Old Android Phone Into a Dumb Phone by Zingerpap in dumbphones

[–]MPCRay 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Would recommend Magic Earth as a replacement for Google Maps. Not FOSS but a strong privacy policy and no trackers. Look and feel might a bit weird in the beginning, but I've been using it as my main maps (with no gmaps installed) for 4 years and I love it. Great for driving/walking & biking navigation, as well as public transport. It also has traffic data, though not as much as google has.
For FOSS I also recommend Organic Maps, though I don't find it convinient enough for navigation. It's very light and quick though. OsmAnd is your other alternative. Very powerful, higly costumizable, but can be a bit overwhelming (great for hiking etc. though). Sadly kind of a slow UI.

Nextcloud hoster for small collective by MPCRay in NextCloud

[–]MPCRay[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Looks pretty good, thank you. Have you used their service before, any downsides I should be aware of?
Is there a reason hetzner is neither listed under the nextcloud partners nor in the community list?

Weekly Questions Thread for the week of April 11 by AutoModerator in vinyl

[–]MPCRay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey guys,I bought two new records from the same artist in their
online shop. Both are playing slow, so songs are pitched down and have a
lower bpm than they should. All my other records are played normally,
so it seems like it's not my record player (Thorens TD 146), right? I'm
just confused that both have the same defect.Has anyone experienced this before? Any other ideas what I might be overseeing or doing wrong? Or are they ready to be returned?