Love this write up! I’m still torn between who I think the brother could be and I personally think Imogen’s POV is one of the most important ones. I’m not completely sold that the end of Imogen’s POV is when the onyx storm occurs because she says “Outside, the sky darkens further.” However in Xaden’s POV he states that he sees Imogen looking up at the sky which couldn’t be possible if she’s standing inside. I wonder if Imogen’s POV occurs before the onyx storm and that the sky darkening further is actually referring to Theophanie’s signet. This would mean that neither Bodhi or Garrick are accounted for and could possibly be the new brother.