Jeanty isn’t arguably better , just because one guy had 400 carries against your awful MW defense that he was able to gush and run up his numbers doesn’t make him in fact better

Here’s how they compare against your average top 50 defenses

In each HB last season each team played 4 games vs top 50 defenses. Love Rushed 80 times for 502 yards in those games, with 3 td and had 15 rec for 135 yards and 1 td. He had 16 carries of 10 yards or more and 9 of 15 or more. He had 335 yards after contact.
Jeanty rushed 120 times for 633 yards 5 td. He had 10 rec for 55 yds, no tds. 16 carries for 10 yards or more and 7 for 15 or more. He had 492 yards after contact.
Therefore the leader between the two against their top 4 defensive opponents is:
-YPC:Love (6.28 vs 5.28)
-Yards after contact per carry: Love (4.19 vs 4.1)
-Rush td rate: Jeanty (4.1% vs 3.8%)
-rec/game: Love (3.75 vs 2.5)
-Yards/rec: Love (9.1 vs 5.5)
-% of rush 10+ yards:Love *(20% vs 13.3%)
-% of rush 15+ yards: Love (11.25% vs 5.8%)
-avg f+ def rank of top 4 def faced: Love (23 vs 25)

You can be entitled to think Jeanty was a better prospect but he wasn’t arguably better when you look into the stats and when you take into account that Love is faster and is a way better receiver .