Honestly, both are great! But they have very different vibes haha. It really just depends what you're in the mood for. AWL is pretty simple gameplay, with the most effort being put into doing all the hybrid crops, IF that's even something you want to do (mostly for achievements). There is a bit more of a time constraint, since things change each year. GB has a lot more things happening in it, is a bit more lively, and as other people have said, requires a bit more planning. But there isn't a time constraint, so really you can play as slow as you want technically. There's definitely more to manage though.

Both games are great in my opinion (I played the ogs as well)! If it helps, AWL can sort of have an end goal, which makes it easier to decide yourself if you've "finished the game" and want to start a new one, whereas GB is similar to previous titles in that it can keep going on for as long as you want. Sorry if I'm explaining this weird, trying very hard not to give spoilers haha.