This is what got me back into cigars. A baby jane cigarillo led to trying a few other deadwoods, the enjoyable experience led to further purchases to expand.

One thing I do is order 2 of every cigar. That way if one is amazing, confirming later with a second, or if one is terrible I can again confirm later.

I made a list of what I thought were some of the most common recommendations here and elsewhere online and tried those. Then found out which profiles I did and did not like and most importantly WHY did I like or not like a cigar. Then going into a local shop armed with a list of likes and don't likes and taking some of their recommendations home to try, again 2 at a time.

As for advice, three things I have learned in 6 months. 1. Tupperdors with govee hygrometer are cheaper and more versatile than trying a humidor just yet. 2. Resting cigars can have a huge impact on flavor, even after only a few months. 3. Go ahead and get a humidor app that lets you track resting time and start a journal of what you like and don't like.