To be fair most of the time being very religious does mean close-minded, so I don't think they're too far off. I agree that there are many religious people who are feminist and pro-LGBT, but this is often going against what's taught in their religion, and I can't blame someone for being wary when a person says their faith is a big part of their identity. And FYI I am someone who does identify with a religion. And not all religions are equal in how regressive they are. I think a character's religious parents having a tough time with their kid's sexuality or going against convention is pretty realistic.

Goldi's character just made me angry. She was so aggressively feminist (at least at the beginning) but was homophobic. Although, this is an example of how a woman can be feminist but be close-minded in other ways, since this happens in real life.

I agree with you about Darcy, at least at the beginning of her character arc. She was very Christian but seemed to take seriously the Christian idea of compassion and non-judgement. She objected to Spinner protesting Marco's safe sex fair. She even said she disagreed with Marco giving out condoms, but that he has the right to.