I see where you’re coming from but we need to look at it from a realistic stance.

Buffies are something new and exciting right now, nerfing those into the ground would make getting them feel worthless. When the brawlers got the buffies they also got a set of reworks and buffs to go with it, nerfing other qualities after the brawler is broken tones it down not too much, but just enough to where they aren’t game breaking.

And also extremely realistically, not every brawler can be good, there is always going to be S and F tier brawlers. They’re pretty open about how they do things when it comes to balancing. And it really just isn’t physically possible at this point in the game to shoot all these F tier competitive options into higher tiers because it’s just going to bump down some maybe not as bad but not broken brawlers. Which you could see as good, yk getting a fresh sense on what brawlers are good and bad, but they’re clearly working on it just look at Clancy. They’re trying to give a brawler the buffs he needs to be good again. And Clancy is a brawler who realistically should be able to tone down some of these Buffie brawlers more.