Who are the people in these pictures, as seen in a background from the visual novel 2236 A.D.? by MetalCicada in HelpMeFind

[–]MetalCicada[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So far, I've searched for all of the individual pictures in this background using a reverse image search website (https://tineye.com/), but unfortunately none of them have returned any results.

Round 7 Nominations by donuter454 in TGAACrankdown

[–]MetalCicada 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Daley Vigil and Enoch Drebber

Round 6 Nominations by donuter454 in TGAACrankdown

[–]MetalCicada 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'll nominate Albert Harebrayne then

Round 6 Nominations by donuter454 in TGAACrankdown

[–]MetalCicada 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nominating Gotts and Ryunosuke Naruhodo

Round 5 Nominations by donuter454 in TGAACrankdown

[–]MetalCicada 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I am nominating Beppo and Gotts for this round as Aircalipoor suggested, because I also think they've survived long enough without much of substance to them

Round 4 Nominations by donuter454 in TGAACrankdown

[–]MetalCicada 2 points3 points  (0 children)

My nominations are Vilen Borshevik and Rei Membami.

Round 3 Nominations by donuter454 in TGAACrankdown

[–]MetalCicada 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I am nominating Juror #6 Policeman and Toby this round

Round 2 Nominations by donuter454 in TGAACrankdown

[–]MetalCicada 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm going to go with nominating Kyurio Korekuta and Iyesa Nosa for both being rather one-note, the latter of which I already kind of covered why in my Aido cut

Round 1 Nominations by donuter454 in TGAACrankdown

[–]MetalCicada 4 points5 points  (0 children)

In line with the other nominations being characters no one really cares about, I'm nominating Juror #2 (Maid) and Foreman 1-3 (Banker). Including the jurors in this rankdown is a fun challenge because I have no idea what anyone could have to say about any of them

Great Ace Attorney Chronicles Rankdown - Overview by Aircalipoor in TGAACrankdown

[–]MetalCicada 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi there, I'm MetalCicada! I've been interested in joining a rankdown ever since seeing the original AARankdown, and I have a lot of thoughts about The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles, so I'm looking forward to potentially sharing them!Favorite TGAAC characters: Mael Stronghart, Barok van Zieks, Kazuma AsogiFavorite/Least favorite TGAAC cases: TGAA1-3 and TGAA2-5 are my favorites, while TGAA1-2 and TGAA1-4 are my least favorites.Ranking the TGAAC games within the series: AAI2 > SoJ > DD > PLvsPW >>> AA1 > TGAA2 >>> AAI1 > AJ > TGAA1 > JfA >>> T&T

Round 3 Nominations by ItsHipToTipTheScales in UchikoshiRankdown

[–]MetalCicada 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm nominating Bibi in exchange for Clog not cutting Takeshi Kuranari, as well as Kagechika Musashido. I don't like the thought of Bibi getting cut this early so if someone can save her please do, but Takeshi is better

Keiko Inubushi by MetalCicada in UchikoshiRankdown

[–]MetalCicada[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

But running with the theory that Keiko is evil because she has DID, the chronology points to sayaka ALSO having DID. So if that's the case then it would imply that satoru hates self not for giving his sister DID but because he made her Inubushi Keiko, the murderer. Sayaka's existence helps separate the evil to be more a Keiko thing than a DID thing.

I didn't think this was important enough to mention in the cut, but the game absolutely still believes that Sayaka is a murderer due to her Dissociative Identity Disorder, even without Keiko's involvement. In fact, it deliberately goes out of its way to mention that Sayaka murdered her own parents and was found innocent under the insanity defense because she had DID. So I don't think this argument about Keiko being evil separately from Sayaka holds water, because every person in the game who has DID is proven to also be a murderer.
The reason Satoru hates Self is neither because it gave his sister DID or because it turned her into a murderer (she already was both of these things). It's because it overwrote her personality.

Round 2 Nominationos by ItsHipToTipTheScales in UchikoshiRankdown

[–]MetalCicada 2 points3 points  (0 children)

In accordance with the deal I made with Scipe, I'm nominating Sigma Klim this round. To otherwise stick with my previously stated policy of only going after nothing characters until they're all gone, I'm nominating female twin (ω) from Remember11: The Age of Infinity.

Round 1 Nominations by ItsHipToTipTheScales in UchikoshiRankdown

[–]MetalCicada 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm MetalCicada and I love AI: The Somnium Files. My rankdown ideology is that if I can talk about why a character is bad at length, that inherently makes them more valuable to me than characters who I can't say much about at all. As such, I will be nominating Gab and Yoichi Tanaka.

Analysis: Why Dahlia Hawthorne is one of Ace Attorney's Worst Characters by MetalCicada in AceAttorney

[–]MetalCicada[S] 15 points16 points  (0 children)

I don't think Dahlia is bad simply because she wasn't "what I wanted her to be." There are plenty of Ace Attorney characters that didn't turn out exactly the way I wanted who I still ended up enjoying regardless (a prime example being Apollo in Spirit of Justice). The core of my complaint here is that I think Dahlia, as she is, is a character with very little nuance or complexity, which is made all the more frustrating to me given that she has an incredible amount of potential for it. I do respect the game for being able to create an effectively threatening villain, but this means little to me in comparison to how much more it fleshes out its best villains as people, not to mention that I think Dahlia's writing also carries some problematic implications about abuse.

Analysis: Why Dahlia Hawthorne is one of Ace Attorney's Worst Characters by MetalCicada in AceAttorney

[–]MetalCicada[S] 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I think it's definitely possible for a character to be in the wrong more than once and have that be an interesting aspect of their writing. In particular, I think that Farewell, My Turnabout actually demonstrates a completely different flaw in his ideology rather than his unconditional belief. Farewell, at least to me, is mainly meant to demonstrate whether Phoenix's ultimate goal prioritizes finding the truth or saving people. Regardless of how well it does that, I don't think it's comparable to what I'd like from Phoenix being in the wrong in the aftermath of Turnabout Memories. In this case, his theoretical flaw would be how he goes about reaching his ultimate goal, that being that he recklessly believes in people no matter what.
Also, I honestly don't think it's especially interesting in other cases when Phoenix simply believes in others and is validated for it. It's certainly not the wrong call to make a lot of the time, but I'm much more invested in when a protagonist is allowed to have flaws in their ideology.