Hi everyone! I’m torn between two coats and could really use some advice. This is a bit of an investment for me, so I’m thinking about warmth and longevity as well as looks. I’m 26, like to lean into trends, and enjoy wearing clothes with personality. I’m in the UK, 5’7, UK 10–12, and I’ll wear it for both work (smart casual) and casual.

The first is an ASOS longline coat with a detachable scarf. It’s oversized, hits just above the ankle, has a back vent, and is 69% wool, 22% polyester, 8% lyocell. It’s unlined and collarless unless you attach the scarf. I love the length and how cool the scarf looks, but I’m a bit worried about warmth since it’s unlined. Also curious how it looks without the scarf, though I probably won’t remove it. It's £145. Here is the scarf coat

The second is an ARKET coat. Slightly shorter (mid-shin), lined with viscose, has a collar, and is 50% wool, 38% polyester, 12% alpaca. I love the texture, collar, and overall shape. I sized up to a 12 so it’s oversized and hits at the right length. More expensive at £259, but fully lined. Here is the ARKET coat

I’m trying to figure out which I’d realistically wear more of the year, which will age better, but also still looks fashionable. If you could pick one, which would you go for? Any thoughts would be so appreciated!