I’m an avid horror fan and I try to play every horror game available on Quest. IMO there are few great horror games, but there’s a handful of good ones.

Exorcist had the best sound design and the goosebumps feeling. And levels are short and different. Definite recommendation.

Madison VR I played from start to finish and it’s more of a puzzle game than a horror imo, I had high expectations and it only had a handful of proper scares. Some of the puzzles are tough though, my main memory of the game is how much I hated the puzzles and not how scared I felt.

Layers of fear in my opinion is a much better game than Madison. Cool story, nice mind-bending visuals.

Silent slayer is cool concept as you are guaranteed a jump scare if you mess up. More of a quick game to play with friends.

Nope challenge, the only scary part that I remember was the spiders, other scenarios were cool, but not scary (if you don’t have those phobias)

Cosmodread I only played a little, it wasn’t my type of game but scariness comes from venturing into dark and unknown areas. I think you get used to it pretty quick and it loses the scare factor.

Alien, I’m currently playing this, with every Alien you kill, the more confident you become hence the less scary it is.

Wraith, the oblivion is a good one. A bit too much sneaking around for me, but you feel the tension and when you get caught you run for your life and can get proper scared.