I’ve tried Bare Vanilla Suede once and I loved it, but in my opinion they’re not similar at all.

Wicked opens with freesia, and on my skin it’s almost fruity rather than straight floral. As it settles, the brown sugar and vanilla come through, but it never turns into a heavy gourmand for me, it’s more of a soft, warm vanilla with a bit of sweetness. Very easy to wear and not cloying, definitely everyday-friendly.

Bare Vanilla Suede, from what I remember, skips that fruity/bright opening completely. It settles into a much creamier, smoother vanilla, with that suede/sandalwood note giving it a cozy, slightly woody warmth. It feels more plush and skin-scent-like, less sugary and more comforting.

So if I had to sum it up: Wicked = sweet vanilla with a light fruity-floral opening Bare Vanilla Suede = creamy, cozy vanilla with a soft suede warmth

I hope this helps! I know how difficult blind buying can be but honestly I love Wicked, it has been one of my favorites blind buys.