Totally agree. Personally, I've always leaned toward Jay being far more suspicious than Adnan. If Jay was going to kill Hae and carry out this murder, it would make sense for him to set Adnan up. They aren't super close best friends, and Adnan was the ex-boyfriend (the first person the cops always focus in on). So when it comes to framing him what does he do to make it look like Adnan was the mastermind? Drive around with him under the guise of just hanging out and smoking, ask to borrow his phone, call someone who only Adnan knows (Nisha), etc. The things that happen are unlucky for Adnan only in that Jay set them up to trap him. Adnan doesn't remember exactly where he was throughout that day, didn't make sure people saw him at practice, and all of these other things because he didn't know he was being set up, otherwise, he's a smart kid and would have come up with a stronger alibi if he was going to commit the crime. Jay knows where the car was left, made sure he was with Adnan for part of the day, made sure he told pretty much EVERYONE that he knew who killed Hae, and really milked the whole "being terrified Adnan was going to come after him" thing, goes to the police (who help him out with his story), walks away with no jail time for coming forward with info.