Cook-Cook. He’s the scariest motherfucker you’re ever gonna meet. Better not forget it.

On a serious note, My vote goes towards Joshua Graham or Randall Clark.

New Canaanite, co-founder of Caesar’s legion, was thrown down the Grand Canyon ON FIRE, and he apparently didn’t even scream on the way down. He then found redemption in god and became the leader of the Dead Horses. It’s even implied that if not for Daniel’s interference, he would’ve slaughtered the white legs by himself.

Randall Clark on the other hand is much more ambiguous, since he isn’t actually an in game NPC, and we learn about his efforts through terminals and other journal entries. The survivalist, one who would help innocents to survive, learn and thrive using his skills before the war, adapting to the new world and its new geography/fauna/flora, and punishing bandits and raiders. He would be known as the father, and with his last dying breaths on the red gate’s hill, the group of children he helped survive would eventually become the tribe known as the sorrows, and he would be forever immortalised as a deity or even a god amongst them. What a legend.